App Submission

RSS for tag

Submit your apps to the App Store using App Store Connect.

Posts under App Submission tag

200 Posts

Post

Replies

Boosts

Views

Activity

Handling ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest
An ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest rejection email looks as follows: ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest- Your app includes "<path/to/SDK>", which includes , an SDK that was identified in the documentation as a privacy-impacting third-party SDK. Starting February 12, 2025, if a new app includes a privacy-impacting SDK, or an app update adds a new privacy-impacting SDK, the SDK must include a privacy manifest file. Please contact the provider of the SDK that includes this file to get an updated SDK version with a privacy manifest. For more details about this policy, including a list of SDKs that are required to include signatures and manifests, visit: https://developer.apple.com/support/third-party-SDK-requirements. Glossary ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest: An email that includes the name and path of privacy-impacting SDK(s) with no privacy manifest files in your app bundle. For more information, see https://developer.apple.com/support/third-party-SDK-requirements. : The specified privacy-impacting SDK that doesn't include a privacy manifest file. If you are the developer of the rejected app, gather the name of the SDK from the email you received from Apple, then contact the SDK's provider for an updated version that includes a valid privacy manifest. After receiving an updated version of the SDK, verify the SDK includes a valid privacy manifest file at the expected location. For more information, see Adding a privacy manifest to your app or third-party SDK. If your app includes a privacy manifest file, make sure the file only describes the privacy practices of your app. Do not add the privacy practices of the SDK to your app's privacy manifest. If the email lists multiple SDKs, repeat the above process for all of them. If you are the developer of an SDK listed in the email, publish an updated version of your SDK that includes a privacy manifest file with valid keys and values. Every privacy-impacting SDK must contain a privacy manifest file that only describes its privacy practices. To learn how to add a valid privacy manifest to your SDK, see the Additional resources section below. Additional resources Privacy manifest files Describing data use in privacy manifests Describing use of required reason API Adding a privacy manifest to your app or third-party SDK TN3182: Adding privacy tracking keys to your privacy manifest TN3183: Adding required reason API entries to your privacy manifest TN3184: Adding data collection details to your privacy manifest TN3181: Debugging an invalid privacy manifest
0
0
8.2k
Mar ’25
New App Rejected Under Guideline 4.3(a) on Both iOS and tvOS — Seeking Clarification
Hi everyone, I’d like to share my experience with the first release of my app and ask for some guidance. Submission details App ID: 6829444660 Platforms: iOS and tvOS (Apple TV) Initially submitted: November 1, 2026, at 7:17 PM Rejection received: November 13, 2026, at 9:30 PM Rejection reason: Guideline 4.3(a) — Design — Spam Both the iOS and Apple TV submissions received the same rejection at the same time. How the app was built I personally developed the app using UIKit, with some parts built in SwiftUI. I also created the visual assets myself using Canva. AI was not involved in writing or designing the app; its involvement was limited to testing-related assistance. Having personally worked on the implementation and visual design, it was discouraging to see the app classified as spam. I believe there may be a misunderstanding about my submission, and I would appreciate an opportunity to clarify it. What I’m asking for Could an Apple representative help identify the specific elements or duplication concerns that led to this rejection? Clear, actionable feedback would help me understand: Which aspects of the app raised concerns under Guideline 4.3(a). What changes, if any, are needed to address those concerns. What supporting information I can provide to help clarify the situation. This project means a lot to me. I respect the review process and want to meet Apple’s requirements. I would sincerely appreciate a reconsideration of my submission and clear guidance on how to move forward. Has anyone experienced a simultaneous 4.3(a) rejection on iOS and tvOS and successfully resolved it? Thank you for taking the time to read this. Any guidance would mean a great deal to me.
2
0
166
50m
Review submission stuck in "Canceling" for 12 days: version locked, can't cancel or resubmit
Our iOS review submission has been stuck in CANCELING since 10 Nov 2026. Every action on it is refused, so we haven't been able to ship an update for 12 days. App ID: 6809173786 Stuck submission: 0c25955e-e5d8-4835-8605-79f8115c9992 Developer Support cases: 103018649498, 103018648320 App Review case: 30000012887740 The submission has 4 items, all still "Ready for Review": iOS App 1.0.14 (app version) Lifetime-Flybud (our first non-consumable IAP) retention-3840x2160.png (Asset Library image) Flybud_Orbit_Header_3840x164… (Asset Library video) What the App Store Connect API returns (22 Nov): Cancel the submission: "Resource state is invalid – Resource cannot be canceled at the moment, please try again later." Remove an item: "Resource state is invalid – Item was already submitted." Add 1.0.14 to a new submission: "Asset Library validation error – Asset is locked by a standalone review submission." Submit the IAP on its own: "The first Non-Consumable In-App Purchase for this app must be submitted for review at the same time that you submit an app version." The version is locked by the stuck submission, and the IAP can only ship with a version, so everything is blocked. New builds upload and process normally. Given error 3, I suspect the Asset Library items are what's preventing the cancellation from completing. Since 10 Nov I've written to App Review four times, opened two Developer Support cases, filed a bug report and emailed the App Store team. Phone support has been unavailable, and App Review can't see the submission in their queue. Could someone at Apple escalate this to App Store Connect engineering to clear or complete the cancellation? Thank you.
0
0
7
58m
Concern Regarding App Review Timeline After Months of Organization Enrollment Delays – Fixit Employee Portal
Hello Apple Developer Community, I am reaching out to seek guidance and express our concern regarding our iOS application, Fixit Employee Portal, which is currently showing "Waiting for Review" in App Store Connect. Application Details: • App Name: Fixit Employee Portal • App Apple ID: 6834282511 • Version: 1.0.4 (Build 2) • Submission Date: November 13, 2026 • Current Status: Waiting for Review Before reaching this stage, our company had already spent several months completing the verification and approval process for our Apple Developer Program organization enrollment. We appreciate Apple's commitment to security, compliance, and quality throughout the enrollment and application review processes. However, after experiencing such an extended enrollment process, we are concerned about the possibility of further significant delays before our application becomes available to our employees. Our application is intended to provide essential employee services to our manpower workforce, including access to employment-related information and company resources. Many of our employees are awaiting its availability on iOS, and timely deployment is important to our daily operations. While we understand that our application was only recently submitted for review, we would sincerely appreciate clarification on the following: Is the current waiting period normal for a newly submitted application under a recently approved organization account? After several months of organization enrollment delays, should we anticipate another extended waiting period for the application review process? Is there a way to confirm that our application has no outstanding requirements that could delay its review? Given our employees' operational need for this application, would an expedited review request be appropriate? We are not requesting that Apple bypass its standard review requirements. We simply hope to understand the expected process and avoid further unnecessary delays after the lengthy organization enrollment experience. We sincerely appreciate the efforts of the Apple Developer and App Review teams and would be grateful for any guidance or assistance. Thank you for your understanding and support. Best regards, Fixit Development Team
2
0
131
15h
“Cannot add for review: too many @@FIELD_VALUE@@s uploaded, maximum is five”, but no asset type exceeds its limit
Hi, I can’t add my app update to review. App Store Connect shows this error (German UI, translated): Cannot be added for review. The following items are required to start the review process: You have uploaded too many @@FIELD_VALUE@@s. A maximum of five is allowed. Original German message: “Du hast zu viele @@FIELD_VALUE@@s hochgeladen. Es sind höchstens fünf zulässig.” The placeholder @@FIELD_VALUE@@ is never replaced, so I can’t tell which asset type the message is about. None of my asset types is anywhere near a limit of five that I’m aware of: App details App: Pockeeper – Taschengeldmanager Apple ID: 6801617068 Platform: iOS Version: 1.0.1 (Build 35), status “Prepare for Submission” Previous version 1.0.0 is “Ready for Distribution” Current assets (German localization) Header (“Kopfzeile”): 1 of 1 Search results content: 1 of 1 iPhone with Dynamic Island (6.1"/6.3"): 0 of 10 screenshots, 0 of 3 previews (“Using existing content” from the previous version) iPhone Duo: 9 of 10 screenshots, 0 of 3 previews iPad 13": 6 of 10 screenshots, 0 of 3 previews Apple Watch: 0 of 10 screenshots Questions Which asset type does this error refer to, and where is the limit of five? Is this related to the new header / search results content or the Content Library? Is this a known issue with the placeholder not being filled in? Thanks for any help!
0
0
68
1d
App Stuck in "Waiting for Review" for 7 Days After Guideline 2.1 Resubmission
Hello everyone, I am looking for advice regarding a delay on my first iOS app submission. It has been continuously in "Waiting for Review" for 7 days, well beyond the typical 24-48 hour window, with no status update. Submission Details: App Apple ID: 6834147398 Version (Build): 1.0 (17) Submission ID: bd2a5346-79a6-4c72-a268-ad797cb9de95 Date Resubmitted: November 13, 2026, 6:48 PM Context & Steps Already Completed: This is a resubmission following a Guideline 2.1 (Information Needed) request. I attached the requested iPhone screen recording demonstrating the app in use and updated the review notes. The app requires no sign-in or account credentials to test. All App Compliance declarations are completed. Agreements, Tax, and Banking show Active. Digital Services Act (DSA) trader compliance and verification documents have been submitted. I have already submitted an Expedited App Review request and an App Store Connect support inquiry, with no response yet. Could anyone, or an Apple team member, advise whether anything might be holding up a Guideline 2.1 resubmission like this, and what I can do to help get the review moving? Thank you in advance for your help. Thank you in advance for your help!
0
0
54
2d
W-8BEN not available in App Store Connect for foreign-owned single-member LLC – only W-9 offered!
Hello, I'm stuck on the tax form step in App Store Connect and would appreciate advice from anyone who has solved this. My situation My company is a US single-member LLC (Wyoming) enrolled in the Apple Developer Program as an organization. I am the sole owner and I live outside the US (Bangladesh). For US tax purposes, the LLC is a foreign-owned disregarded entity (no Form 8832 election), so the correct form should be Form W-8BEN in my name as the beneficial owner, not Form W-9. The problem In App Store Connect → Business → Tax Forms, only "U.S. Form W-9" is offered. The "+" button also opens only the W-9. Because the tax form is incomplete, my Paid Apps Agreement shows "Pending User Info", my bank account has shown "Processing" for over a week, and my App Store Small Business Program enrollment is on hold. What I've done Nov 11: contacted Apple Finance via Contact Us → Reports and Payments → Tax and Banking Setup, asking them to enable Form W-8BEN. Received an automatic acknowledgment with a case ID. Nov 17: followed up by replying to that email. No response yet. Nov 19: contacted Developer Support (Membership and Account → Program Enrolment) to keep the Small Business Program enrollment open and ask them to escalate to Finance. Questions Has anyone with a foreign-owned single-member LLC had Apple Finance switch their tax form from W-9 to W-8BEN? How long did it take? Is there a faster way to reach Apple Finance, or a specific contact topic that works better? Did anyone have to provide documents (for example the IRS EIN letter CP 575 or Form SS-4) to get W-8BEN enabled? Any experience or advice would be very helpful. Thank you!
0
0
32
2d
My request for Expedited review was granted at start, 3 rejections(the latter was due to app screenshots issue which was already fixed), our launch date is overdue. Please help.
App: Horra: Your Ultimate Reminder (Apple ID: 6830636232) Build: 1.0.0 (14) Platform: IOS Submission ID 6edfee1a-33e8-4320-90c7-514a64b77240 The first rejection was due to a lack of screen recording showning the app flow, it was provided The second rejection was due to an audio issue and compliance which was fixed. The third is Metadata(app screenshots), we uploaded new screenshots. Please I would appreciate a Reviewer to get on this as our app launch date is overdue. Thank you!
0
1
136
2d
Expedite granted at the start, 3 rejections from reviewer sign-in mistakes, and now stuck in "Waiting for Review
App: Cannon VoIP (Apple ID 6826007596) Platform: iOS Current build: 3.4.1826 First submitted: October 23, 2026 Expedited review: requested and granted at the start, and we were told it covers the whole process Current status: Waiting for Review Why this is urgent: we found a security vulnerability in an older legacy platform we used to run our customers on. To protect them, we had to move every customer off that platform right away. The old platform had an iPhone app; our new one is waiting on this review. Until it's approved, our customers' iPhone users have no way to make and take their business calls. These are small businesses that depend on their phones, and it's causing them real distress. That's why we asked for an expedited review when we first submitted on October 23. It was granted, and we were told it applies to the whole review process, resubmissions included. Nearly four weeks later, the app still isn't live. Rejections 1 and 2 (Guideline 2.1): App Review said they couldn't sign in and kept asking us to turn off two-factor authentication on the demo account. The demo account doesn't use two-factor. The review notes give a username and password, and entering them signs you straight in. Instead, the reviewer pressed the option to send a sign-in code by email. That code goes to our support inbox, which the reviewer can't see, so they got stuck and rejected the app. There was nothing for us to turn off. Entering the username and password is all it takes. Rejection 3: the reviewer declined the microphone permission. This is a business phone app, and calls can't work without the microphone. At the time, declining it sent the user back to the sign-in screen, and the app was rejected for that. We've already fixed that in the current build. If the microphone is declined, the app no longer signs the person out. It stays signed in and shows a clear message saying the microphone is needed for calls and how to turn it on. That build is the one now waiting. Despite the expedite, it has sat in Waiting for Review since. We haven't uploaded another build, because we don't want to lose our place. We've called Developer Support several times a day. Every call means 2 to 3.5 hours on hold, and every time we get the same answer: it's in the queue, wait. Nothing changes. For comparison: Our Mac app, with the same sign-in screen and the same demo account, was approved quickly by Apple. Our Android app, submitted at the same time, was approved by Google in under 12 hours. Same app, same sign-in, same account. So this isn't a hard app to review, and "we're busy" doesn't explain four weeks with an expedite granted. What we're asking: Can someone at App Review check why a submission with an expedite already granted hasn't been picked up? Please have the reviewer sign in with the username and password in the review notes. Don't press "email me a code". The account has no two-factor to disable. Please allow the microphone when asked. It's a calling app. If it's declined, the app now explains how to turn it on. Our customers are waiting on this app to make and take their business calls. We'd appreciate a look. Brayden Cannon CEO Cannon VoIP
1
0
94
2d
Stuck in “Waiting for Review” after over a week — anyone else experiencing delays?
Hi everyone, Our iOS app has been waiting for more than a week, and review has not yet started. We have already submitted an expedited review request and contacted Apple Developer Support, but the status remains “Waiting for Review.” We have a health system pilot launching in early December. Participating care team members need time to download the app, sign in, and become familiar with it before launch. Our Android app submitted at the same time is already published on Google Play, though we expect most participants in this pilot to use iPhones. Our biggest concern is that we haven’t received any review feedback yet. If changes and a resubmission are needed, we’ll need time to make those changes and complete another review. With the initial review still pending, we’re worried about how much time will remain to address any issues and prepare users for launch. We’re a very small startup, and this pilot is critical to our ability to bring the app to additional health system clients. The uncertainty is becoming difficult to plan around as a small team. Has anyone recently experienced a similar wait before review even started? How long did it take, and did anything help move things forward after you submitted an expedited request? We planned our submission based on Apple’s published goal of reviewing 90% of submissions in less than 48 hours, allowing time ahead of our pilot for potential revisions. We understand that individual reviews can take longer, but our own delay and reports of further waits after resubmission have made it difficult to know what timeline to expect. At this point, we really need to hear directly from an Apple representative to understand whether anything is outstanding on our side, whether our review can be expedited, and how to plan for the remaining steps. We’re ready to act on any feedback, but we need that communication to move forward. App details Apple ID: 6779812852 Version: iOS 1.0.0 P.S. -- If you’re experiencing the same issue, please consider boosting this thread and sharing how long you’ve been waiting. Hopefully we can bring more visibility to these delays and get some guidance from Apple on what to expect.
2
1
121
2d
Automated 2.5.1 "not submitted with the Family Controls entitlement" although entitlement is assigned and in the build
My first submission was stopped by an automated App Review message, and I can't find anything on my side to fix. It looks the same as the reports in thread 838802. The message (Guideline 2.5.1): "An automated analysis indicates the app uses one or more Screen Time APIs but the app has not been submitted with the Family Controls entitlement." App Name: blorbs, Apple ID 6836228369 Bundle ID: app.blorb.ios, Team ID: WVVPTV9U33 Version 1.0.0 (1), submitted Nov 18, 2026, 1:29 AM PT Automated message received Nov 18, 10:34 AM PT Submission ID: 4d3288f6-3a5b-48cb-8f1e-20fc01a55c14 Built with Xcode 26.6 (iOS 26.5 SDK), minimum iOS 17, automatic signing What the app is A personal focus app. The user picks apps to lock on their own device (individual authorization) and unlocks them by tapping an NFC accessory. Targets: the main app, a DeviceActivityMonitor extension, a ShieldConfiguration extension, and a widget / Live Activity extension. What I verified Approval: Apple Developer Relations emailed on Nov 11, 2026 that Family Controls (Distribution) "has been assigned to your account". Portal: Capability Requests shows Family Controls (Distribution) as Assigned on app.blorb.ios, app.blorb.ios.monitor and app.blorb.ios.shield. Provisioning Support lists Development, Ad hoc, App Store Connect. The uploaded build: App Store Connect > TestFlight > Build Metadata > Entitlements shows com.apple.developer.family-controls: true on the main app, the monitor extension and the shield extension. Binary State: Validated. The widget extension has no Screen Time code and links none of FamilyControls, ManagedSettings, ManagedSettingsUI or DeviceActivity, so it correctly has no entitlement. What the app does not use No App and Website Usage entitlement, no approvedWithDataAccess, no FamilyActivityData No DeviceActivityReport extension, no ShieldAction extension The only related calls are Application.localizedDisplayName and WebDomain.domain, read inside the ShieldConfigurationDataSource to show the name of the shielded app or site, as the documentation describes. What I've done Replied in App Store Connect with the details above Submitted an appeal to the App Review Board Questions Could someone from App Review or DTS check whether this automated flag is correct for this submission, and whether it's blocking reviewer assignment? Can the message say which binary or API triggered it? Apple's own record of the build lists the entitlement on every Screen Time binary. Has anyone had this cleared, and what did it take? Happy to share build IDs, entitlement dumps or anything else privately.
1
0
229
2d
Unlisted App Distribution – 12 Days Without Any Response Despite Multiple Support Requests
Hello Apple Developer Community and Apple Staff, I would like to express my frustration with the ongoing delay and lack of communication regarding our Unlisted App Distribution Request for ALVI Logistic. Timeline: November 7 – Submitted the Unlisted App Distribution Request. November 9 – Application rejected under Guideline 3.2. November 10 – Contacted Apple Developer Support. November 12 – Submitted a follow-up request. November 17 – Formally requested escalation to a Senior Advisor. November 19 – Still no meaningful response. It has now been 12 calendar days since our original request, despite Apple's confirmation stating that we would receive a response within three business days. Our application is fully developed and intended for approximately 5–10 restaurant employees using their personal iPhones. As a paying member of the Apple Developer Program, I find this lack of communication extremely disappointing. Our business client is waiting for the completed application, and we cannot proceed without Apple's decision. We are not asking for immediate approval. We are simply asking for a response and a clear status update. Has anyone experienced a similar situation? How did you resolve it? Could an Apple representative please help us escalate this issue? Thank you. MAGE TEAM s.r.o. Slovakia
0
0
72
2d
First submission stuck in "Waiting for Review" since Nov 15 despite approved expedited review (App ID 6812280475)
Hello App Review team, Our app PropLoop (App ID 6812280475), iOS 1.0 build 43, has been in "Waiting for Review" since Sunday November 15, 2026. It has not moved to "In Review". The expedited review was approved on November 18. We also contacted App Review support and have no reply yet. There is no rejection, no message and nothing pending in App Store Connect. The demo account in the review notes has been checked and works. Many users are waiting for the app, and our launch is planned before the end of November. Could you check if the submission is stuck, and if anything is needed from us? Thank you, The PropLoop team
0
0
35
3d
Version 1.0.0 stuck in "Waiting for Review" for ~2 weeks after an automated Guideline 2.5.1 message about the Family Controls entitlement
Our app — a screen-time / focus app — has had no App Review activity for two weeks, and we believe the trigger was an automated Guideline 2.5.1 check that froze an otherwise actively progressing review. (This forum account is linked to the developer account in question; we can provide the App ID, bundle IDs, submission IDs, and support case numbers through any private channel on request.) Context: Jul 2–5: Our first submission (Version 1.0.0) was under active review. We went through several ordinary metadata / paywall-related iterations, and the reviewer responded within roughly 24 hours each time. Nothing related to Screen Time was raised in these human reviews of builds 9 and 10. Jul 8: After we submitted build 11 — which addressed the remaining human-review feedback — we received an automated Guideline 2.5.1 (Performance: Software Requirements) message stating that the app uses the Screen Time API but has not been submitted with the Family Controls entitlement, and that review of the submission cannot proceed. All reviewer activity stopped at that point, and there has been none since. What we verified: The Family Controls (Distribution) entitlement is granted to our account and assigned to all four bundle IDs (the main app plus its DeviceActivityMonitor, ShieldAction, and ShieldConfiguration extensions). We verified with codesign that com.apple.developer.family-controls = true is present in the code signature and embedded provisioning profile of every one of the four executables in the submitted IPA — so the entitlement named in the automated message is present in the flagged build. For context: builds 9 and 10, with an identical Screen Time API surface and identical entitlements (verified at the binary level with nm against the submitted artifacts), had been human-reviewed on Jul 2–5 with no Screen Time-related objection. We recognize those builds may simply not have reached the automated analysis stage before being superseded, so we do not draw firm conclusions from that. What we did anyway (build 12, submitted Jul 9): In case the automated check actually concerns the separate com.apple.developer.family-controls.app-and-website-usage entitlement (which we do not request and do not need), we removed every reference from our main app to the APIs associated with it: AuthorizationStatus.approvedWithDataAccess, ManagedSettings.Application.bundleIdentifier, ManagedSettings.Application.localizedDisplayName, ManagedSettings.ActivityCategory.localizedDisplayName, and ManagedSettings.WebDomain.domain. We verified with nm that none of the four executables in the build 12 IPA reference these APIs. The app does not use FamilyActivityData, DeviceActivityReport, app usage events, web usage events, or App and Website Usage data access. No automated message has appeared for build 12. What has happened since: Jul 9–14: No reviewer activity on build 12. We filed an expedited review request and opened two Developer Support cases (Jul 8 and Jul 14). No response to any of them. Around Jul 15: Hoping to clear the frozen state, we cancelled and resubmitted the same Version 1.0.0 / build 12. Around Jul 17: Filed a second expedited review request for the new submission. Jul 22 (today): The new submission has been in "Waiting for Review" since Jul 15, with no reviewer activity and no reply to either support case or either expedite request. What we are asking: Could someone check whether the Jul 8 automated flag is still attached to the app record and blocking reviewer assignment, and help get the current submission assigned to a reviewer? If the automated check flags build 12 again, could the message specify which entitlement and which binary / API references triggered it, so we can address it precisely? We can provide codesign output, entitlement plists, provisioning profile dumps, and nm symbol listings on request. Thank you.
4
2
1.3k
3d
Significantly Delayed App Review
Hi all, Like others my app submission has been stuck in “waiting for review” for weeks. I know initial app reviews take longer than updates, but this has been delayed far too long and makes me concerned about repeating the process in the future. I submitted this app for review back on Feb 10. It was initially rejected for a minor issue, which I resolved and resubmitted the same day. After that, the build remained in “Waiting for Review” for about two weeks with no further communication. At that point I canceled the submission and resubmitted the build, thinking it may have been stuck in the queue (I now know not to do this next time). Unfortunately the new submission has also been waiting for review for another 9 days now with no messages or updates. I’ve contacted app review support as well (case ID- 102826632729). I understand review times can vary, but delays like this make it difficult for developers to plan launches or push updates when the review process is the only path to distributing apps. As paying members of the Apple Developer Program, we rely heavily on this pipeline functioning reliably. Hoping this post will reach someone from Apple who can help move the process along. If any other devs have suggestions/tips that have worked for them, please share so others in this position can become unblocked. Thanks in advance.
27
20
5.4k
4d
Mac app stuck in "Waiting for Review" for over 10 days
My Mac app Media Toolkit has been in "Waiting for Review" since 7 November 2026 (more than 10 days), and the status hasn't changed. Submission details App: Media Toolkit Platform: macOS (Mac App Store) Version / Build: 1.0 (1) Bundle ID: in.todomist.mediatoolkit.mac Submitted: 7 November 2026 Type: first submission of a new app What I've checked There are no messages or requests in App Store Connect or the Resolution Center Agreements, tax and banking are all active No other version has been submitted since Has anyone else seen long waits for macOS submissions recently? Is there anything I should check on my side? If someone from App Review sees this, I'd be grateful if you could look at the submission.
0
0
21
4d
iOS 1.0 in "Waiting for Review" since Nov 11 after an Information Needed resubmission (expedite accepted, macOS approved)
Hello, Our iOS app DashNovel (Apple ID 6814248100) has been in "Waiting for Review" since Nov 11, and I would like to confirm that the submission is correctly queued. Timeline (Pacific Time): Nov 10, 3:35 PM: Submitted iOS 1.0 (build 26) together with our first subscription group and two auto-renewable subscriptions (monthly and yearly). Nov 10, about 9:06 PM: Received "Guideline 2.1 - Information Needed - New App Submission". The same day, we added the requested screen recording and details to App Review Information and resubmitted. Nov 11: We removed the submission from review to switch to build 27 (the only change: Restore Purchases now shows a result alert), then resubmitted at 12:33 AM together with the subscription group and both subscriptions. Submission ID: b717efcf-1390-4c4b-800b-c2022e1291fd Nov 13: Requested expedited review for iOS and macOS. Both requests were accepted. Nov 13, about 4:40 PM: macOS 1.0 (the same build 27, submitted at the same time) was approved after about 10 minutes in review. As of today: iOS 1.0 is still "Waiting for Review". There are no messages in App Store Connect, and the earlier Information Needed thread no longer has a reply option. Developer Support (case 30000006277096) confirmed the status and said no further action is needed if an expedite was requested. Because the subscriptions were submitted with the iOS version, we are holding the approved macOS release until the iOS version is reviewed. Could someone from App Review please check whether this submission is correctly in the expedited queue, and let us know if anything is needed from our side? We are happy to provide anything further. Thank you.
0
0
154
4d
Guidelines 4.3(a) and 4.2.6: Publishing separate apps for multiple companies under one or separate developer accounts
Hello everyone, I’m developing a work management app using React Native/Expo for multiple companies. The apps share a common codebase and similar core functionality, but each company has its own app name, logo, bundle ID, and company-specific data. Each company wants a separate app publicly available on the App Store so users can search for and download it. Private distribution through Custom Apps or a single shared app with a company selector would not meet their requirements. I’d like to understand how App Review Guidelines 4.3(a) and 4.2.6 apply to these two scenarios: 1. All apps published under one organization’s developer account Our company would develop and publish all client apps under our own Apple Developer Program organization account. Is there a compliant way to support this model? What requirements would each app need to meet? 2. Each app published under the client company’s own developer account Each client company would enroll in the Apple Developer Program and publish its app under its own organization account, while our team handles development and assists with submission. Could these apps still be rejected under Guideline 4.3(a) because they share a codebase and similar functionality? For both scenarios, I’d appreciate clarification on the following: What differences in functionality, content, or business workflows would help establish each app as a distinct product? How does Guideline 4.2.6 apply to this shared-platform model? What supporting documentation should we provide, such as development contracts or letters of authorization? How should we explain the business need for separate apps in App Review Notes? Has anyone successfully implemented a similar model? I’m looking for a compliant, sustainable approach, rather than a workaround to the review guidelines. Thank you for your advice and experience.
1
0
161
4d
Unbelievable: 2 App Store rejections, ZERO uses of our app's main feature. What would you do - appeal or resubmit?
I'm genuinely at a loss with Apple's App Review process. Our backend records show that across BOTH reviews, Apple's reviewers did not complete a SINGLE use of our app's core functionality. Not once. ZERO completed generations. For the latest review, our logs confirm Apple successfully logged in, but recorded ZERO generation requests and ZERO credits consumed. This isn't some minor feature. It's the entire foundation of our app. Our app fundamentally changes and becomes personalised as it's used. Without completing that process, you're essentially judging an incomplete product. Submission ID: 6a126514-9bb6-4d91-923c-bf29aacb1b68 Here's why this is so frustrating. We spent months deliberately building an app that offers functionality and a user experience fundamentally different from existing competitors. This wasn't another copycat app - avoiding that was central to its design from day one. We explained these differences extensively in our App Review notes. Yet Apple has rejected us TWICE under Guideline 4.3(b) — Design Spam. We even provided a narrated walkthrough demonstrating exactly what makes our app unique. Our video analytics show ZERO views. So we're being rejected for supposedly lacking originality, despite neither review producing a completed use of our main feature and no recorded views of our demonstration. After both rejections, we've received nothing but generic responses telling us to improve the app, without identifying a single specific problem. How are independent developers supposed to fix something when Apple won't explain what's wrong? We've now filed a formal appeal, which could take a month, with no visible queue position, progress updates or estimated timeframe. Meanwhile, we've already missed multiple planned marketing opportunities, and waiting could mean missing even more. We're not asking for guaranteed approval. We're asking for a fair review of what we've actually built. Has anyone else experienced this? What would you do? Wait for the appeal, hoping the App Review Board properly evaluates the app, even if it takes another month and we miss more deadlines? Withdraw the appeal and resubmit, hoping for a different reviewer, but risking another rejection without proper testing and further warnings against our developer account? I'd genuinely appreciate advice from anyone who's experienced something similar, especially those who've successfully appealed a 4.3(b) rejection. At this point, I genuinely don't know whether this is a reviewer misunderstanding, an automated rejection process, or something else entirely. But how can Apple determine that an app lacks originality when its defining functionality hasn't even been tested?
18
1
1k
5d
App Stuck In Review Since October 26, 2026 — No Updates Despite Multiple Support Requests
Hello, I'm reaching out regarding an ongoing issue with an iOS application that has been stuck in the "In Review" status since October 26, 2026. As of today, November 13, the application has been in review for 18 days without any updates, rejection notices, requests for additional information, or communication explaining the delay. I've published multiple applications through the App Store before, and while I understand that review times can vary, I've never experienced anything remotely close to this. I've reached out to Apple Developer Support multiple times, sent approximately five emails, and even spent nearly three hours on hold trying to speak with someone who could provide some information. I've also submitted an expedited review request, which unfortunately hasn't resulted in any progress either. I even spoke with a support representative who mentioned that they would try to push the issue forward, but despite all these attempts, I still haven't received any meaningful updates or explanations. This delay has significantly affected my business, and it's incredibly frustrating to have an application sitting in review for this long without knowing what's happening or whether anything is actually being done. I completely understand that certain applications might require additional review time, and I have no issue with that. However, I would at least expect some form of communication, especially after nearly three weeks and multiple attempts to contact support. At this point, I'm genuinely concerned that the application might be stuck in Apple's review system or that something has gone wrong internally. Has anyone experienced a similar situation where an application remained specifically in "In Review" for this long? Is there any way to reach someone directly from the App Review team or escalate this beyond the standard support channels? I've already tried requesting an expedited review without success, so I'm unsure what other options are available. I'd appreciate any guidance or assistance, especially from someone at Apple who might be able to look into this. Thank you.
3
2
282
5d
App Stuck in Review for Over a Month – Already Published on Google Play with Strong User Interest
Hello Apple App Review Team, I am an independent game developer, and my game has been stuck in the App Review process for approximately one month without a final decision. Submission ID: e1dfbdc4-ed91-4e02-acf5-1de15461d895 My application has been awaiting review for an unusually long period. After several weeks without progress, I canceled the previous submission and submitted it again, hoping to resolve the delay. Unfortunately, the latest submission is still in "Waiting for Review", with no further updates or explanation. I would also like to highlight that my game is already published on Google Play, where it has attracted significant user interest and exceeded 10,000 downloads. Google Play link: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.alpsoft.kus The game is actively available to Android users, and I am eager to make it available to iOS users as well. As an independent developer, I have invested considerable time and effort into creating and improving this game. The prolonged review delay is affecting my ability to reach new players and expand to another platform. I fully understand that Apple needs to carefully review applications before publication. However, I would sincerely appreciate assistance in understanding why my submission has remained pending for so long. Could an Apple App Review representative please: Investigate the reason for this unusually long delay. Confirm whether anything is preventing my application from entering active review. Escalate my submission to the appropriate team. Provide an update or guidance on any further steps required. I am not requesting automatic approval or special treatment. I simply hope my game can receive a fair and timely review. Thank you for your time and assistance. I would greatly appreciate any help in resolving this situation. Best regards, Independent Game Developer
2
0
424
5d
Handling ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest
An ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest rejection email looks as follows: ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest- Your app includes "<path/to/SDK>", which includes , an SDK that was identified in the documentation as a privacy-impacting third-party SDK. Starting February 12, 2025, if a new app includes a privacy-impacting SDK, or an app update adds a new privacy-impacting SDK, the SDK must include a privacy manifest file. Please contact the provider of the SDK that includes this file to get an updated SDK version with a privacy manifest. For more details about this policy, including a list of SDKs that are required to include signatures and manifests, visit: https://developer.apple.com/support/third-party-SDK-requirements. Glossary ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest: An email that includes the name and path of privacy-impacting SDK(s) with no privacy manifest files in your app bundle. For more information, see https://developer.apple.com/support/third-party-SDK-requirements. : The specified privacy-impacting SDK that doesn't include a privacy manifest file. If you are the developer of the rejected app, gather the name of the SDK from the email you received from Apple, then contact the SDK's provider for an updated version that includes a valid privacy manifest. After receiving an updated version of the SDK, verify the SDK includes a valid privacy manifest file at the expected location. For more information, see Adding a privacy manifest to your app or third-party SDK. If your app includes a privacy manifest file, make sure the file only describes the privacy practices of your app. Do not add the privacy practices of the SDK to your app's privacy manifest. If the email lists multiple SDKs, repeat the above process for all of them. If you are the developer of an SDK listed in the email, publish an updated version of your SDK that includes a privacy manifest file with valid keys and values. Every privacy-impacting SDK must contain a privacy manifest file that only describes its privacy practices. To learn how to add a valid privacy manifest to your SDK, see the Additional resources section below. Additional resources Privacy manifest files Describing data use in privacy manifests Describing use of required reason API Adding a privacy manifest to your app or third-party SDK TN3182: Adding privacy tracking keys to your privacy manifest TN3183: Adding required reason API entries to your privacy manifest TN3184: Adding data collection details to your privacy manifest TN3181: Debugging an invalid privacy manifest
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
8.2k
Activity
Mar ’25
New App Rejected Under Guideline 4.3(a) on Both iOS and tvOS — Seeking Clarification
Hi everyone, I’d like to share my experience with the first release of my app and ask for some guidance. Submission details App ID: 6829444660 Platforms: iOS and tvOS (Apple TV) Initially submitted: November 1, 2026, at 7:17 PM Rejection received: November 13, 2026, at 9:30 PM Rejection reason: Guideline 4.3(a) — Design — Spam Both the iOS and Apple TV submissions received the same rejection at the same time. How the app was built I personally developed the app using UIKit, with some parts built in SwiftUI. I also created the visual assets myself using Canva. AI was not involved in writing or designing the app; its involvement was limited to testing-related assistance. Having personally worked on the implementation and visual design, it was discouraging to see the app classified as spam. I believe there may be a misunderstanding about my submission, and I would appreciate an opportunity to clarify it. What I’m asking for Could an Apple representative help identify the specific elements or duplication concerns that led to this rejection? Clear, actionable feedback would help me understand: Which aspects of the app raised concerns under Guideline 4.3(a). What changes, if any, are needed to address those concerns. What supporting information I can provide to help clarify the situation. This project means a lot to me. I respect the review process and want to meet Apple’s requirements. I would sincerely appreciate a reconsideration of my submission and clear guidance on how to move forward. Has anyone experienced a simultaneous 4.3(a) rejection on iOS and tvOS and successfully resolved it? Thank you for taking the time to read this. Any guidance would mean a great deal to me.
Replies
2
Boosts
0
Views
166
Activity
50m
Review submission stuck in "Canceling" for 12 days: version locked, can't cancel or resubmit
Our iOS review submission has been stuck in CANCELING since 10 Nov 2026. Every action on it is refused, so we haven't been able to ship an update for 12 days. App ID: 6809173786 Stuck submission: 0c25955e-e5d8-4835-8605-79f8115c9992 Developer Support cases: 103018649498, 103018648320 App Review case: 30000012887740 The submission has 4 items, all still "Ready for Review": iOS App 1.0.14 (app version) Lifetime-Flybud (our first non-consumable IAP) retention-3840x2160.png (Asset Library image) Flybud_Orbit_Header_3840x164… (Asset Library video) What the App Store Connect API returns (22 Nov): Cancel the submission: "Resource state is invalid – Resource cannot be canceled at the moment, please try again later." Remove an item: "Resource state is invalid – Item was already submitted." Add 1.0.14 to a new submission: "Asset Library validation error – Asset is locked by a standalone review submission." Submit the IAP on its own: "The first Non-Consumable In-App Purchase for this app must be submitted for review at the same time that you submit an app version." The version is locked by the stuck submission, and the IAP can only ship with a version, so everything is blocked. New builds upload and process normally. Given error 3, I suspect the Asset Library items are what's preventing the cancellation from completing. Since 10 Nov I've written to App Review four times, opened two Developer Support cases, filed a bug report and emailed the App Store team. Phone support has been unavailable, and App Review can't see the submission in their queue. Could someone at Apple escalate this to App Store Connect engineering to clear or complete the cancellation? Thank you.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
7
Activity
58m
Concern Regarding App Review Timeline After Months of Organization Enrollment Delays – Fixit Employee Portal
Hello Apple Developer Community, I am reaching out to seek guidance and express our concern regarding our iOS application, Fixit Employee Portal, which is currently showing "Waiting for Review" in App Store Connect. Application Details: • App Name: Fixit Employee Portal • App Apple ID: 6834282511 • Version: 1.0.4 (Build 2) • Submission Date: November 13, 2026 • Current Status: Waiting for Review Before reaching this stage, our company had already spent several months completing the verification and approval process for our Apple Developer Program organization enrollment. We appreciate Apple's commitment to security, compliance, and quality throughout the enrollment and application review processes. However, after experiencing such an extended enrollment process, we are concerned about the possibility of further significant delays before our application becomes available to our employees. Our application is intended to provide essential employee services to our manpower workforce, including access to employment-related information and company resources. Many of our employees are awaiting its availability on iOS, and timely deployment is important to our daily operations. While we understand that our application was only recently submitted for review, we would sincerely appreciate clarification on the following: Is the current waiting period normal for a newly submitted application under a recently approved organization account? After several months of organization enrollment delays, should we anticipate another extended waiting period for the application review process? Is there a way to confirm that our application has no outstanding requirements that could delay its review? Given our employees' operational need for this application, would an expedited review request be appropriate? We are not requesting that Apple bypass its standard review requirements. We simply hope to understand the expected process and avoid further unnecessary delays after the lengthy organization enrollment experience. We sincerely appreciate the efforts of the Apple Developer and App Review teams and would be grateful for any guidance or assistance. Thank you for your understanding and support. Best regards, Fixit Development Team
Replies
2
Boosts
0
Views
131
Activity
15h
“Cannot add for review: too many @@FIELD_VALUE@@s uploaded, maximum is five”, but no asset type exceeds its limit
Hi, I can’t add my app update to review. App Store Connect shows this error (German UI, translated): Cannot be added for review. The following items are required to start the review process: You have uploaded too many @@FIELD_VALUE@@s. A maximum of five is allowed. Original German message: “Du hast zu viele @@FIELD_VALUE@@s hochgeladen. Es sind höchstens fünf zulässig.” The placeholder @@FIELD_VALUE@@ is never replaced, so I can’t tell which asset type the message is about. None of my asset types is anywhere near a limit of five that I’m aware of: App details App: Pockeeper – Taschengeldmanager Apple ID: 6801617068 Platform: iOS Version: 1.0.1 (Build 35), status “Prepare for Submission” Previous version 1.0.0 is “Ready for Distribution” Current assets (German localization) Header (“Kopfzeile”): 1 of 1 Search results content: 1 of 1 iPhone with Dynamic Island (6.1"/6.3"): 0 of 10 screenshots, 0 of 3 previews (“Using existing content” from the previous version) iPhone Duo: 9 of 10 screenshots, 0 of 3 previews iPad 13": 6 of 10 screenshots, 0 of 3 previews Apple Watch: 0 of 10 screenshots Questions Which asset type does this error refer to, and where is the limit of five? Is this related to the new header / search results content or the Content Library? Is this a known issue with the placeholder not being filled in? Thanks for any help!
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
68
Activity
1d
App Stuck in "Waiting for Review" for 7 Days After Guideline 2.1 Resubmission
Hello everyone, I am looking for advice regarding a delay on my first iOS app submission. It has been continuously in "Waiting for Review" for 7 days, well beyond the typical 24-48 hour window, with no status update. Submission Details: App Apple ID: 6834147398 Version (Build): 1.0 (17) Submission ID: bd2a5346-79a6-4c72-a268-ad797cb9de95 Date Resubmitted: November 13, 2026, 6:48 PM Context & Steps Already Completed: This is a resubmission following a Guideline 2.1 (Information Needed) request. I attached the requested iPhone screen recording demonstrating the app in use and updated the review notes. The app requires no sign-in or account credentials to test. All App Compliance declarations are completed. Agreements, Tax, and Banking show Active. Digital Services Act (DSA) trader compliance and verification documents have been submitted. I have already submitted an Expedited App Review request and an App Store Connect support inquiry, with no response yet. Could anyone, or an Apple team member, advise whether anything might be holding up a Guideline 2.1 resubmission like this, and what I can do to help get the review moving? Thank you in advance for your help. Thank you in advance for your help!
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
54
Activity
2d
W-8BEN not available in App Store Connect for foreign-owned single-member LLC – only W-9 offered!
Hello, I'm stuck on the tax form step in App Store Connect and would appreciate advice from anyone who has solved this. My situation My company is a US single-member LLC (Wyoming) enrolled in the Apple Developer Program as an organization. I am the sole owner and I live outside the US (Bangladesh). For US tax purposes, the LLC is a foreign-owned disregarded entity (no Form 8832 election), so the correct form should be Form W-8BEN in my name as the beneficial owner, not Form W-9. The problem In App Store Connect → Business → Tax Forms, only "U.S. Form W-9" is offered. The "+" button also opens only the W-9. Because the tax form is incomplete, my Paid Apps Agreement shows "Pending User Info", my bank account has shown "Processing" for over a week, and my App Store Small Business Program enrollment is on hold. What I've done Nov 11: contacted Apple Finance via Contact Us → Reports and Payments → Tax and Banking Setup, asking them to enable Form W-8BEN. Received an automatic acknowledgment with a case ID. Nov 17: followed up by replying to that email. No response yet. Nov 19: contacted Developer Support (Membership and Account → Program Enrolment) to keep the Small Business Program enrollment open and ask them to escalate to Finance. Questions Has anyone with a foreign-owned single-member LLC had Apple Finance switch their tax form from W-9 to W-8BEN? How long did it take? Is there a faster way to reach Apple Finance, or a specific contact topic that works better? Did anyone have to provide documents (for example the IRS EIN letter CP 575 or Form SS-4) to get W-8BEN enabled? Any experience or advice would be very helpful. Thank you!
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
32
Activity
2d
My request for Expedited review was granted at start, 3 rejections(the latter was due to app screenshots issue which was already fixed), our launch date is overdue. Please help.
App: Horra: Your Ultimate Reminder (Apple ID: 6830636232) Build: 1.0.0 (14) Platform: IOS Submission ID 6edfee1a-33e8-4320-90c7-514a64b77240 The first rejection was due to a lack of screen recording showning the app flow, it was provided The second rejection was due to an audio issue and compliance which was fixed. The third is Metadata(app screenshots), we uploaded new screenshots. Please I would appreciate a Reviewer to get on this as our app launch date is overdue. Thank you!
Replies
0
Boosts
1
Views
136
Activity
2d
Expedite granted at the start, 3 rejections from reviewer sign-in mistakes, and now stuck in "Waiting for Review
App: Cannon VoIP (Apple ID 6826007596) Platform: iOS Current build: 3.4.1826 First submitted: October 23, 2026 Expedited review: requested and granted at the start, and we were told it covers the whole process Current status: Waiting for Review Why this is urgent: we found a security vulnerability in an older legacy platform we used to run our customers on. To protect them, we had to move every customer off that platform right away. The old platform had an iPhone app; our new one is waiting on this review. Until it's approved, our customers' iPhone users have no way to make and take their business calls. These are small businesses that depend on their phones, and it's causing them real distress. That's why we asked for an expedited review when we first submitted on October 23. It was granted, and we were told it applies to the whole review process, resubmissions included. Nearly four weeks later, the app still isn't live. Rejections 1 and 2 (Guideline 2.1): App Review said they couldn't sign in and kept asking us to turn off two-factor authentication on the demo account. The demo account doesn't use two-factor. The review notes give a username and password, and entering them signs you straight in. Instead, the reviewer pressed the option to send a sign-in code by email. That code goes to our support inbox, which the reviewer can't see, so they got stuck and rejected the app. There was nothing for us to turn off. Entering the username and password is all it takes. Rejection 3: the reviewer declined the microphone permission. This is a business phone app, and calls can't work without the microphone. At the time, declining it sent the user back to the sign-in screen, and the app was rejected for that. We've already fixed that in the current build. If the microphone is declined, the app no longer signs the person out. It stays signed in and shows a clear message saying the microphone is needed for calls and how to turn it on. That build is the one now waiting. Despite the expedite, it has sat in Waiting for Review since. We haven't uploaded another build, because we don't want to lose our place. We've called Developer Support several times a day. Every call means 2 to 3.5 hours on hold, and every time we get the same answer: it's in the queue, wait. Nothing changes. For comparison: Our Mac app, with the same sign-in screen and the same demo account, was approved quickly by Apple. Our Android app, submitted at the same time, was approved by Google in under 12 hours. Same app, same sign-in, same account. So this isn't a hard app to review, and "we're busy" doesn't explain four weeks with an expedite granted. What we're asking: Can someone at App Review check why a submission with an expedite already granted hasn't been picked up? Please have the reviewer sign in with the username and password in the review notes. Don't press "email me a code". The account has no two-factor to disable. Please allow the microphone when asked. It's a calling app. If it's declined, the app now explains how to turn it on. Our customers are waiting on this app to make and take their business calls. We'd appreciate a look. Brayden Cannon CEO Cannon VoIP
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
94
Activity
2d
Stuck in “Waiting for Review” after over a week — anyone else experiencing delays?
Hi everyone, Our iOS app has been waiting for more than a week, and review has not yet started. We have already submitted an expedited review request and contacted Apple Developer Support, but the status remains “Waiting for Review.” We have a health system pilot launching in early December. Participating care team members need time to download the app, sign in, and become familiar with it before launch. Our Android app submitted at the same time is already published on Google Play, though we expect most participants in this pilot to use iPhones. Our biggest concern is that we haven’t received any review feedback yet. If changes and a resubmission are needed, we’ll need time to make those changes and complete another review. With the initial review still pending, we’re worried about how much time will remain to address any issues and prepare users for launch. We’re a very small startup, and this pilot is critical to our ability to bring the app to additional health system clients. The uncertainty is becoming difficult to plan around as a small team. Has anyone recently experienced a similar wait before review even started? How long did it take, and did anything help move things forward after you submitted an expedited request? We planned our submission based on Apple’s published goal of reviewing 90% of submissions in less than 48 hours, allowing time ahead of our pilot for potential revisions. We understand that individual reviews can take longer, but our own delay and reports of further waits after resubmission have made it difficult to know what timeline to expect. At this point, we really need to hear directly from an Apple representative to understand whether anything is outstanding on our side, whether our review can be expedited, and how to plan for the remaining steps. We’re ready to act on any feedback, but we need that communication to move forward. App details Apple ID: 6779812852 Version: iOS 1.0.0 P.S. -- If you’re experiencing the same issue, please consider boosting this thread and sharing how long you’ve been waiting. Hopefully we can bring more visibility to these delays and get some guidance from Apple on what to expect.
Replies
2
Boosts
1
Views
121
Activity
2d
Automated 2.5.1 "not submitted with the Family Controls entitlement" although entitlement is assigned and in the build
My first submission was stopped by an automated App Review message, and I can't find anything on my side to fix. It looks the same as the reports in thread 838802. The message (Guideline 2.5.1): "An automated analysis indicates the app uses one or more Screen Time APIs but the app has not been submitted with the Family Controls entitlement." App Name: blorbs, Apple ID 6836228369 Bundle ID: app.blorb.ios, Team ID: WVVPTV9U33 Version 1.0.0 (1), submitted Nov 18, 2026, 1:29 AM PT Automated message received Nov 18, 10:34 AM PT Submission ID: 4d3288f6-3a5b-48cb-8f1e-20fc01a55c14 Built with Xcode 26.6 (iOS 26.5 SDK), minimum iOS 17, automatic signing What the app is A personal focus app. The user picks apps to lock on their own device (individual authorization) and unlocks them by tapping an NFC accessory. Targets: the main app, a DeviceActivityMonitor extension, a ShieldConfiguration extension, and a widget / Live Activity extension. What I verified Approval: Apple Developer Relations emailed on Nov 11, 2026 that Family Controls (Distribution) "has been assigned to your account". Portal: Capability Requests shows Family Controls (Distribution) as Assigned on app.blorb.ios, app.blorb.ios.monitor and app.blorb.ios.shield. Provisioning Support lists Development, Ad hoc, App Store Connect. The uploaded build: App Store Connect > TestFlight > Build Metadata > Entitlements shows com.apple.developer.family-controls: true on the main app, the monitor extension and the shield extension. Binary State: Validated. The widget extension has no Screen Time code and links none of FamilyControls, ManagedSettings, ManagedSettingsUI or DeviceActivity, so it correctly has no entitlement. What the app does not use No App and Website Usage entitlement, no approvedWithDataAccess, no FamilyActivityData No DeviceActivityReport extension, no ShieldAction extension The only related calls are Application.localizedDisplayName and WebDomain.domain, read inside the ShieldConfigurationDataSource to show the name of the shielded app or site, as the documentation describes. What I've done Replied in App Store Connect with the details above Submitted an appeal to the App Review Board Questions Could someone from App Review or DTS check whether this automated flag is correct for this submission, and whether it's blocking reviewer assignment? Can the message say which binary or API triggered it? Apple's own record of the build lists the entitlement on every Screen Time binary. Has anyone had this cleared, and what did it take? Happy to share build IDs, entitlement dumps or anything else privately.
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
229
Activity
2d
Unlisted App Distribution – 12 Days Without Any Response Despite Multiple Support Requests
Hello Apple Developer Community and Apple Staff, I would like to express my frustration with the ongoing delay and lack of communication regarding our Unlisted App Distribution Request for ALVI Logistic. Timeline: November 7 – Submitted the Unlisted App Distribution Request. November 9 – Application rejected under Guideline 3.2. November 10 – Contacted Apple Developer Support. November 12 – Submitted a follow-up request. November 17 – Formally requested escalation to a Senior Advisor. November 19 – Still no meaningful response. It has now been 12 calendar days since our original request, despite Apple's confirmation stating that we would receive a response within three business days. Our application is fully developed and intended for approximately 5–10 restaurant employees using their personal iPhones. As a paying member of the Apple Developer Program, I find this lack of communication extremely disappointing. Our business client is waiting for the completed application, and we cannot proceed without Apple's decision. We are not asking for immediate approval. We are simply asking for a response and a clear status update. Has anyone experienced a similar situation? How did you resolve it? Could an Apple representative please help us escalate this issue? Thank you. MAGE TEAM s.r.o. Slovakia
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
72
Activity
2d
First submission stuck in "Waiting for Review" since Nov 15 despite approved expedited review (App ID 6812280475)
Hello App Review team, Our app PropLoop (App ID 6812280475), iOS 1.0 build 43, has been in "Waiting for Review" since Sunday November 15, 2026. It has not moved to "In Review". The expedited review was approved on November 18. We also contacted App Review support and have no reply yet. There is no rejection, no message and nothing pending in App Store Connect. The demo account in the review notes has been checked and works. Many users are waiting for the app, and our launch is planned before the end of November. Could you check if the submission is stuck, and if anything is needed from us? Thank you, The PropLoop team
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
35
Activity
3d
Version 1.0.0 stuck in "Waiting for Review" for ~2 weeks after an automated Guideline 2.5.1 message about the Family Controls entitlement
Our app — a screen-time / focus app — has had no App Review activity for two weeks, and we believe the trigger was an automated Guideline 2.5.1 check that froze an otherwise actively progressing review. (This forum account is linked to the developer account in question; we can provide the App ID, bundle IDs, submission IDs, and support case numbers through any private channel on request.) Context: Jul 2–5: Our first submission (Version 1.0.0) was under active review. We went through several ordinary metadata / paywall-related iterations, and the reviewer responded within roughly 24 hours each time. Nothing related to Screen Time was raised in these human reviews of builds 9 and 10. Jul 8: After we submitted build 11 — which addressed the remaining human-review feedback — we received an automated Guideline 2.5.1 (Performance: Software Requirements) message stating that the app uses the Screen Time API but has not been submitted with the Family Controls entitlement, and that review of the submission cannot proceed. All reviewer activity stopped at that point, and there has been none since. What we verified: The Family Controls (Distribution) entitlement is granted to our account and assigned to all four bundle IDs (the main app plus its DeviceActivityMonitor, ShieldAction, and ShieldConfiguration extensions). We verified with codesign that com.apple.developer.family-controls = true is present in the code signature and embedded provisioning profile of every one of the four executables in the submitted IPA — so the entitlement named in the automated message is present in the flagged build. For context: builds 9 and 10, with an identical Screen Time API surface and identical entitlements (verified at the binary level with nm against the submitted artifacts), had been human-reviewed on Jul 2–5 with no Screen Time-related objection. We recognize those builds may simply not have reached the automated analysis stage before being superseded, so we do not draw firm conclusions from that. What we did anyway (build 12, submitted Jul 9): In case the automated check actually concerns the separate com.apple.developer.family-controls.app-and-website-usage entitlement (which we do not request and do not need), we removed every reference from our main app to the APIs associated with it: AuthorizationStatus.approvedWithDataAccess, ManagedSettings.Application.bundleIdentifier, ManagedSettings.Application.localizedDisplayName, ManagedSettings.ActivityCategory.localizedDisplayName, and ManagedSettings.WebDomain.domain. We verified with nm that none of the four executables in the build 12 IPA reference these APIs. The app does not use FamilyActivityData, DeviceActivityReport, app usage events, web usage events, or App and Website Usage data access. No automated message has appeared for build 12. What has happened since: Jul 9–14: No reviewer activity on build 12. We filed an expedited review request and opened two Developer Support cases (Jul 8 and Jul 14). No response to any of them. Around Jul 15: Hoping to clear the frozen state, we cancelled and resubmitted the same Version 1.0.0 / build 12. Around Jul 17: Filed a second expedited review request for the new submission. Jul 22 (today): The new submission has been in "Waiting for Review" since Jul 15, with no reviewer activity and no reply to either support case or either expedite request. What we are asking: Could someone check whether the Jul 8 automated flag is still attached to the app record and blocking reviewer assignment, and help get the current submission assigned to a reviewer? If the automated check flags build 12 again, could the message specify which entitlement and which binary / API references triggered it, so we can address it precisely? We can provide codesign output, entitlement plists, provisioning profile dumps, and nm symbol listings on request. Thank you.
Replies
4
Boosts
2
Views
1.3k
Activity
3d
Significantly Delayed App Review
Hi all, Like others my app submission has been stuck in “waiting for review” for weeks. I know initial app reviews take longer than updates, but this has been delayed far too long and makes me concerned about repeating the process in the future. I submitted this app for review back on Feb 10. It was initially rejected for a minor issue, which I resolved and resubmitted the same day. After that, the build remained in “Waiting for Review” for about two weeks with no further communication. At that point I canceled the submission and resubmitted the build, thinking it may have been stuck in the queue (I now know not to do this next time). Unfortunately the new submission has also been waiting for review for another 9 days now with no messages or updates. I’ve contacted app review support as well (case ID- 102826632729). I understand review times can vary, but delays like this make it difficult for developers to plan launches or push updates when the review process is the only path to distributing apps. As paying members of the Apple Developer Program, we rely heavily on this pipeline functioning reliably. Hoping this post will reach someone from Apple who can help move the process along. If any other devs have suggestions/tips that have worked for them, please share so others in this position can become unblocked. Thanks in advance.
Replies
27
Boosts
20
Views
5.4k
Activity
4d
Mac app stuck in "Waiting for Review" for over 10 days
My Mac app Media Toolkit has been in "Waiting for Review" since 7 November 2026 (more than 10 days), and the status hasn't changed. Submission details App: Media Toolkit Platform: macOS (Mac App Store) Version / Build: 1.0 (1) Bundle ID: in.todomist.mediatoolkit.mac Submitted: 7 November 2026 Type: first submission of a new app What I've checked There are no messages or requests in App Store Connect or the Resolution Center Agreements, tax and banking are all active No other version has been submitted since Has anyone else seen long waits for macOS submissions recently? Is there anything I should check on my side? If someone from App Review sees this, I'd be grateful if you could look at the submission.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
21
Activity
4d
iOS 1.0 in "Waiting for Review" since Nov 11 after an Information Needed resubmission (expedite accepted, macOS approved)
Hello, Our iOS app DashNovel (Apple ID 6814248100) has been in "Waiting for Review" since Nov 11, and I would like to confirm that the submission is correctly queued. Timeline (Pacific Time): Nov 10, 3:35 PM: Submitted iOS 1.0 (build 26) together with our first subscription group and two auto-renewable subscriptions (monthly and yearly). Nov 10, about 9:06 PM: Received "Guideline 2.1 - Information Needed - New App Submission". The same day, we added the requested screen recording and details to App Review Information and resubmitted. Nov 11: We removed the submission from review to switch to build 27 (the only change: Restore Purchases now shows a result alert), then resubmitted at 12:33 AM together with the subscription group and both subscriptions. Submission ID: b717efcf-1390-4c4b-800b-c2022e1291fd Nov 13: Requested expedited review for iOS and macOS. Both requests were accepted. Nov 13, about 4:40 PM: macOS 1.0 (the same build 27, submitted at the same time) was approved after about 10 minutes in review. As of today: iOS 1.0 is still "Waiting for Review". There are no messages in App Store Connect, and the earlier Information Needed thread no longer has a reply option. Developer Support (case 30000006277096) confirmed the status and said no further action is needed if an expedite was requested. Because the subscriptions were submitted with the iOS version, we are holding the approved macOS release until the iOS version is reviewed. Could someone from App Review please check whether this submission is correctly in the expedited queue, and let us know if anything is needed from our side? We are happy to provide anything further. Thank you.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
154
Activity
4d
Guidelines 4.3(a) and 4.2.6: Publishing separate apps for multiple companies under one or separate developer accounts
Hello everyone, I’m developing a work management app using React Native/Expo for multiple companies. The apps share a common codebase and similar core functionality, but each company has its own app name, logo, bundle ID, and company-specific data. Each company wants a separate app publicly available on the App Store so users can search for and download it. Private distribution through Custom Apps or a single shared app with a company selector would not meet their requirements. I’d like to understand how App Review Guidelines 4.3(a) and 4.2.6 apply to these two scenarios: 1. All apps published under one organization’s developer account Our company would develop and publish all client apps under our own Apple Developer Program organization account. Is there a compliant way to support this model? What requirements would each app need to meet? 2. Each app published under the client company’s own developer account Each client company would enroll in the Apple Developer Program and publish its app under its own organization account, while our team handles development and assists with submission. Could these apps still be rejected under Guideline 4.3(a) because they share a codebase and similar functionality? For both scenarios, I’d appreciate clarification on the following: What differences in functionality, content, or business workflows would help establish each app as a distinct product? How does Guideline 4.2.6 apply to this shared-platform model? What supporting documentation should we provide, such as development contracts or letters of authorization? How should we explain the business need for separate apps in App Review Notes? Has anyone successfully implemented a similar model? I’m looking for a compliant, sustainable approach, rather than a workaround to the review guidelines. Thank you for your advice and experience.
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
161
Activity
4d
Unbelievable: 2 App Store rejections, ZERO uses of our app's main feature. What would you do - appeal or resubmit?
I'm genuinely at a loss with Apple's App Review process. Our backend records show that across BOTH reviews, Apple's reviewers did not complete a SINGLE use of our app's core functionality. Not once. ZERO completed generations. For the latest review, our logs confirm Apple successfully logged in, but recorded ZERO generation requests and ZERO credits consumed. This isn't some minor feature. It's the entire foundation of our app. Our app fundamentally changes and becomes personalised as it's used. Without completing that process, you're essentially judging an incomplete product. Submission ID: 6a126514-9bb6-4d91-923c-bf29aacb1b68 Here's why this is so frustrating. We spent months deliberately building an app that offers functionality and a user experience fundamentally different from existing competitors. This wasn't another copycat app - avoiding that was central to its design from day one. We explained these differences extensively in our App Review notes. Yet Apple has rejected us TWICE under Guideline 4.3(b) — Design Spam. We even provided a narrated walkthrough demonstrating exactly what makes our app unique. Our video analytics show ZERO views. So we're being rejected for supposedly lacking originality, despite neither review producing a completed use of our main feature and no recorded views of our demonstration. After both rejections, we've received nothing but generic responses telling us to improve the app, without identifying a single specific problem. How are independent developers supposed to fix something when Apple won't explain what's wrong? We've now filed a formal appeal, which could take a month, with no visible queue position, progress updates or estimated timeframe. Meanwhile, we've already missed multiple planned marketing opportunities, and waiting could mean missing even more. We're not asking for guaranteed approval. We're asking for a fair review of what we've actually built. Has anyone else experienced this? What would you do? Wait for the appeal, hoping the App Review Board properly evaluates the app, even if it takes another month and we miss more deadlines? Withdraw the appeal and resubmit, hoping for a different reviewer, but risking another rejection without proper testing and further warnings against our developer account? I'd genuinely appreciate advice from anyone who's experienced something similar, especially those who've successfully appealed a 4.3(b) rejection. At this point, I genuinely don't know whether this is a reviewer misunderstanding, an automated rejection process, or something else entirely. But how can Apple determine that an app lacks originality when its defining functionality hasn't even been tested?
Replies
18
Boosts
1
Views
1k
Activity
5d
App Stuck In Review Since October 26, 2026 — No Updates Despite Multiple Support Requests
Hello, I'm reaching out regarding an ongoing issue with an iOS application that has been stuck in the "In Review" status since October 26, 2026. As of today, November 13, the application has been in review for 18 days without any updates, rejection notices, requests for additional information, or communication explaining the delay. I've published multiple applications through the App Store before, and while I understand that review times can vary, I've never experienced anything remotely close to this. I've reached out to Apple Developer Support multiple times, sent approximately five emails, and even spent nearly three hours on hold trying to speak with someone who could provide some information. I've also submitted an expedited review request, which unfortunately hasn't resulted in any progress either. I even spoke with a support representative who mentioned that they would try to push the issue forward, but despite all these attempts, I still haven't received any meaningful updates or explanations. This delay has significantly affected my business, and it's incredibly frustrating to have an application sitting in review for this long without knowing what's happening or whether anything is actually being done. I completely understand that certain applications might require additional review time, and I have no issue with that. However, I would at least expect some form of communication, especially after nearly three weeks and multiple attempts to contact support. At this point, I'm genuinely concerned that the application might be stuck in Apple's review system or that something has gone wrong internally. Has anyone experienced a similar situation where an application remained specifically in "In Review" for this long? Is there any way to reach someone directly from the App Review team or escalate this beyond the standard support channels? I've already tried requesting an expedited review without success, so I'm unsure what other options are available. I'd appreciate any guidance or assistance, especially from someone at Apple who might be able to look into this. Thank you.
Replies
3
Boosts
2
Views
282
Activity
5d
App Stuck in Review for Over a Month – Already Published on Google Play with Strong User Interest
Hello Apple App Review Team, I am an independent game developer, and my game has been stuck in the App Review process for approximately one month without a final decision. Submission ID: e1dfbdc4-ed91-4e02-acf5-1de15461d895 My application has been awaiting review for an unusually long period. After several weeks without progress, I canceled the previous submission and submitted it again, hoping to resolve the delay. Unfortunately, the latest submission is still in "Waiting for Review", with no further updates or explanation. I would also like to highlight that my game is already published on Google Play, where it has attracted significant user interest and exceeded 10,000 downloads. Google Play link: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.alpsoft.kus The game is actively available to Android users, and I am eager to make it available to iOS users as well. As an independent developer, I have invested considerable time and effort into creating and improving this game. The prolonged review delay is affecting my ability to reach new players and expand to another platform. I fully understand that Apple needs to carefully review applications before publication. However, I would sincerely appreciate assistance in understanding why my submission has remained pending for so long. Could an Apple App Review representative please: Investigate the reason for this unusually long delay. Confirm whether anything is preventing my application from entering active review. Escalate my submission to the appropriate team. Provide an update or guidance on any further steps required. I am not requesting automatic approval or special treatment. I simply hope my game can receive a fair and timely review. Thank you for your time and assistance. I would greatly appreciate any help in resolving this situation. Best regards, Independent Game Developer
Replies
2
Boosts
0
Views
424
Activity
5d