Discuss how to secure user data, respect user data preferences, support iCloud Private Relay and Mail Privacy Protection, replace CAPTCHAs with Private Access Tokens, and more. Ask about Privacy nutrition labels, Privacy manifests, and more.

Posts under Privacy tag

200 Posts

Post

Replies

Boosts

Views

Activity

Handling ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest
An ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest rejection email looks as follows: ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest- Your app includes "<path/to/SDK>", which includes , an SDK that was identified in the documentation as a privacy-impacting third-party SDK. Starting February 12, 2025, if a new app includes a privacy-impacting SDK, or an app update adds a new privacy-impacting SDK, the SDK must include a privacy manifest file. Please contact the provider of the SDK that includes this file to get an updated SDK version with a privacy manifest. For more details about this policy, including a list of SDKs that are required to include signatures and manifests, visit: https://developer.apple.com/support/third-party-SDK-requirements. Glossary ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest: An email that includes the name and path of privacy-impacting SDK(s) with no privacy manifest files in your app bundle. For more information, see https://developer.apple.com/support/third-party-SDK-requirements. : The specified privacy-impacting SDK that doesn't include a privacy manifest file. If you are the developer of the rejected app, gather the name of the SDK from the email you received from Apple, then contact the SDK's provider for an updated version that includes a valid privacy manifest. After receiving an updated version of the SDK, verify the SDK includes a valid privacy manifest file at the expected location. For more information, see Adding a privacy manifest to your app or third-party SDK. If your app includes a privacy manifest file, make sure the file only describes the privacy practices of your app. Do not add the privacy practices of the SDK to your app's privacy manifest. If the email lists multiple SDKs, repeat the above process for all of them. If you are the developer of an SDK listed in the email, publish an updated version of your SDK that includes a privacy manifest file with valid keys and values. Every privacy-impacting SDK must contain a privacy manifest file that only describes its privacy practices. To learn how to add a valid privacy manifest to your SDK, see the Additional resources section below. Additional resources Privacy manifest files Describing data use in privacy manifests Describing use of required reason API Adding a privacy manifest to your app or third-party SDK TN3182: Adding privacy tracking keys to your privacy manifest TN3183: Adding required reason API entries to your privacy manifest TN3184: Adding data collection details to your privacy manifest TN3181: Debugging an invalid privacy manifest
0
0
8.2k
Mar ’25
Privacy Resources
General: Forums topic: Privacy & Security Forums tag: Privacy Developer > Security — This also covers privacy topics. App privacy details on the App Store UIKit > Protecting the User’s Privacy documentation Bundle Resources > Privacy manifest files documentation TN3181 Debugging an invalid privacy manifest technote TN3182 Adding privacy tracking keys to your privacy manifest technote TN3183 Adding required reason API entries to your privacy manifest technote TN3184 Adding data collection details to your privacy manifest technote TN3179 Understanding local network privacy technote Handling ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest forums post Share and Enjoy — Quinn “The Eskimo!” @ Developer Technical Support @ Apple let myEmail = "eskimo" + "1" + "@" + "apple.com"
0
0
710
Jul ’25
Screen Recording permission popup not shown & app not added to app list in Screen Recording settings
Requesting the Screen Recording permission seems broken on macOS 27.3 beta 2. I'd love to know whether this change is intentional or whether we can expect a fix before the stable macOS 27.3 release. Feedback report: FB25646769 Behavior until macOS 27.2 When an app calls CGRequestScreenCaptureAccess(), macOS shows the following popup: Additionally, the app is added to the app list in the “Screen & System Audio Recording” panel in the System Settings. It is toggled off by default and the user can easily toggle it on. Behavior on macOS 27.3 beta 2 When an app calls CGRequestScreenCaptureAccess(), no popup appears and the app is not added to the app list in the “Screen & System Audio Recording” panel in the System Settings. The user cannot easily grant the permission. What the user has to do to grant the permission on macOS 27.3 beta 2 It is not intuitive for the user to figure out how to grant the Screen Recording permission. Without any guidance, the user needs to: Click the little plus icon below the app list in the "Screen & System Audio Recording” panel in the System Settings Because the System Settings panel shows two app lists, the user needs to click the plus icon below the correct app list ("Screen & System Audio Recording", not "System Audio Recording Only") Find the app in the file picker and add it This is cumbersome and unintuitive. There's no explanation of what to do. The average user will be confused and will struggle to complete these tasks. Reproduction steps Install an app that requests the Screen Recording permission (e.g., Cap) Get to the onboarding step that requests the Screen Recording permission Observe that the permission request popup is not shown and that the app is not added to the System Settings panel
3
1
140
1d
Reading Mouse Events with CGEvent tap from a background app in macOS 27.3
WIth macOS 27.3 (beta 2) things have changed quite a bit for security, see Updates to Device Control and Data Access, and Full Disk Access in macOS I have an app which uses what (used to be called) the Privacy & Security / Accessibility permissions in order to receive mouse events in the background to read them and occasionally modify them. The method used: The app checks AXIsProcessTrustedWithOptions to see if it has permission. If it doesn't have permission, it uses the kAXTrustedCheckOptionPrompt option which would open up the privacy & Security / Accessibility pane. Because that process has been a little flakey in macOS, my app has a backup option, where it runs 'open "x-apple.systempreferences:com.apple.settings.PrivacySecurity.extension?Privacy_Accessibility"' and then walks the user through the steps with onscreen instructions. When permission is granted, the app creates a CGEvent tap SessionEvent tap using the HeadInsertEvent option to receive mouse and touch mouse events. See CGEvent.tapCreate In macOS 27.3 beta 2, always returns false using kAXTrustedCheckOptionPrompt fails to do anything open "x-apple.systempreferences:com.apple.settings.PrivacySecurity.extension?Privacy_Accessibility fails to do anything. CGEvent tap fails A few questions: will my third party app be allowed to use CGEventTaps to read mouse and touchpad events? Or has this been cut off completely and only available to first party apps? If it is allowed, how? Has the permission for this moved to a different System Preference pane? is a CGEvent tap the way to do it? I totally understand that security is important, and apps should not have wide-ranging permissions. I'd love to find a way to keep my app running with the minimal permissions needed.
5
0
515
2d
ATT prompt not shown and status stays notDetermined: how do you handle it?
Hello, our Unity game (iOS/iPadOS) requests App Tracking Transparency on its first scene, before ads are initialized. Background App Review rejected an earlier build under Guideline 2.1(a) for a blank screen on iPad Air 11-inch (M3), iPadOS 27.0. In that build we called requestTrackingAuthorization right at launch and then waited until trackingAuthorizationStatus was no longer .notDetermined. The status never changed, so the app never left the first screen. Current flow (this build was approved) Wait until UIApplication.shared.applicationState == .active and the app has focus. Call requestTrackingAuthorization(completionHandler:) once and wait for the completion handler. If the completion returns .notDetermined, wait about 4 seconds while the app stays active, then call it one more time. Wait until the status is no longer .notDetermined before loading the next scene. There is no timeout. The first scene runs on every cold launch, so if the status is still .notDetermined, the request is made again on the next launch. [ATTrackingManager requestTrackingAuthorizationWithCompletionHandler:^(ATTrackingManagerAuthorizationStatus status) { dispatch_async(dispatch_get_main_queue(), ^{ // store status; Unity polls it on the main thread }); }];We have not been able to reproduce the original problem on our own devices. Questions for those who have shipped apps with ATT How many times do you retry requestTrackingAuthorization, and how long do you wait between attempts? Is there any limit you know of? If the status still stays .notDetermined after retrying, do you let the user continue and treat it as not authorized (no IDFA), or keep waiting? If you wait, how long before you let the user continue? If you continue without tracking, did App Review ever flag that? Any experience or pointers to documentation would be appreciated.
0
0
31
2d
macOS 27: Accessibility granted via MDM doesn’t cover PostEvent, and leaves a stray TCC managed_overrides row after unenrollment
Our app uses an active CGEventTap (kCGEventTapOptionDefault, mouse down/up events) and relies on the Accessibility permission (Device Control & Data Access). CGEventTapCreate(kCGAnnotatedSessionEventTap, kCGHeadInsertEventTap, kCGEventTapOptionDefault, CGEventMaskBit(kCGEventLeftMouseDown) | CGEventMaskBit(kCGEventLeftMouseUp) | CGEventMaskBit(kCGEventRightMouseDown) | CGEventMaskBit(kCGEventRightMouseUp) | CGEventMaskBit(kCGEventOtherMouseDown) | CGEventMaskBit(kCGEventOtherMouseUp), callback, refcon);On macOS 27.0.1 we see two behaviours when that permission comes from MDM, and we’d like to know whether they’re expected. According to the PrivacyPreferencesPolicyControl.Services documentation, the PPPC Accessibility key is deprecated in macOS 27. It’s replaced by the Privacy → PermissionDefaults setting in the declarative configuration com.apple.configuration.app.settings, and the managed value is a default that the user can change. We tested both the PPPC payload and the DDM configuration. 1. Managed Accessibility grant doesn’t cover PostEvent When the user turns on Accessibility manually in System Settings > Privacy & Security > Accessibility, the event tap works with no further prompts. When Accessibility comes from device management (a PPPC payload or DDM PermissionDefaults): AXIsProcessTrusted() returns true. On the first click through the tap, macOS shows the “control this computer” prompt. tccd adds an access row for kTCCServicePostEvent with auth_value 0 and auth_reason 4. At the same moment, the app’s Accessibility toggle in System Settings switches off. The managed Accessibility row remains auth_value 2, auth_reason 6. After the user accepts the prompt, PostEvent changes to auth_value 2 and the tap works from then on. Questions : Why does a manual Accessibility grant cover an active event tap, while a managed Accessibility default needs a separate PostEvent grant? With PPPC Accessibility deprecated, is DDM Accessibility plus PPPC PostEvent (Allowed) the intended configuration for apps that install active event taps? 2. Stray managed_overrides row after unenrollment On macOS 27, the managed Accessibility value is stored in a new managed_overrides table in /Library/Application Support/com.apple.TCC/TCC.db (schema version 36). On macOS 15 and 26, managed grants were kept in MDMOverrides.plist, and this table doesn’t exist there. Steps : Enroll a never-managed Mac in MDM with user-approved enrollment. Install a profile that grants Accessibility to our app. tccd logs ManagedSettings: inserted managed_overrides for kTCCServiceAccessibility:<bundle id> admin_auth_value=2 auth_value=2. The row is written with policy_id NULL, and policies and active_policy stay empty. Remove the MDM profile from System Settings > General > Device Management. What happens: mdmclient removes the MDM profile first. Removing each TCC payload after that fails with : PlugIn: DetermineUninstallFlags [TCCProfileService] Error: Error Domain=NSPOSIXErrorDomain Code=13 "Permission denied" UserInfo={NSLocalizedDescription=The profile must originate from a user-approved MDM server.}The profiles disappear, MDMOverrides.plist is deleted, and profiles status reports no MDM enrollment. The row remains, with auth_value 1, auth_reason 6 (MDM Policy), policy_id NULL, admin_auth_value 2 and flags 480. tccutil reset Accessibility <bundle id> clears flags but doesn’t remove the row. Later permission prompts and System Settings toggles for the app write to this row instead of to access. Why does the row stay after unenrollment? Is there a supported way to clear it?
2
1
238
2d
macOS 27.3 Accessibility Entitlements
I saw that Apple announced they intend to only notarize applications with the upcoming accessibility entitlement (macOS 27.3) if those applications provide assistive technologies. Would a tool that records meetings and uses the accessibility API to access meeting metadata (participant names, speaker labels, etc) qualify for this? What are the criteria that Apple are evaluating against to determine eligibility for this entitlement?
1
2
244
2d
Network Extension URL Filter registration pending review for more than a month
Hello, I am writing about a Network Extension URL Filter configuration submitted through the Identity & Trust section of the CloudKit Console on 5 September 2026 Status shown: In Review / Waiting for Approval Last Modified: 5 September 2026 (unchanged since submission) It has now been 37 days with no response — no approval, no rejection, and no request for changes. The PIR server , Privacy Pass issuer and HTTP/2 OHTTP gateway have been live and serving since the day of submission, configured per the Onboarding.md guidance in Apple's PIR service example, including the apple-url-filter DNS TXT record on the service URL and the url-filter-test validation entry. Could anyone please let me know: Whether this configuration is actually in a review queue, and the expected timeframe; Whether anything further is required from our side — if so, we will act on it the same day. The URL filter is a core protection feature of our app, which is currently in App Store review; the feature stays disabled for users until this registration is approved, so the delay is holding up what we can ship. Thank you for your help.
5
0
319
2d
Full Disk Access on macOS 27.3
I'm looking into the changes being implemented and I find this way of handling by Apple on short notice problematic. Now our customers (those that don't have MDM) will have to jump through hoops to enable FDA for our product, a security product that also uses Endpoint Security. We already have the entitlement for endpoint security, which requires FDA in order to work, so why make it so difficult instead of just allowing FDA for apps that have this entitlement? Why only backup applications are exempted?
2
0
130
3d
Local Network Privacy Child Process Behavior
I have a Java Swing application that is bundled into an app bundle using jpackage. The app basically launches a newer version of itself, when there is a new version downloaded in the users installation directory. I have noticed a regression or change in behavior with how LocalNetwork privacy works now. Previously, we would launch our Java application using the .app bundle. This is a launcher that checks for updates and will launch another JVM instance using any new jars it downloads when updating. So, it is closing the original process and spawning a new process using the downloaded jar. The new process is where the app connects to a server on the Local Network. This new process cannot access the Local Network even when the entry in privacy and security is enabled for the parent process. I have changed the behavior of my launcher application so that it keeps the process alive after launching the client application. When doing this, Local Network access works. So, my question is: is it required for the parent process to be running in order for a child process to have Local Network access? In previous macOS versions, this was not an issue, so something has changed with Local Network security across all the latest versions 26 and 27.
8
0
256
5d
MobileVLCKit (3.7.3) triggering Local Network permission
The problem manifests itself from 16 to 18 iOS not inclusive Versions from 18 up to and including do not cause this problem. When initializing the player, a request for permission to use the local network appears. The application does not use a local network as a capability, even in plist there is no such key. Apple has granted permission to use multicast networking, and the corresponding capability has also been added. The player is assembled as let player = VLCMediaPlayer() player.media = mediaHaving previously collected media with the options "clock-synchro=..." "avcodec-threads=..." "rtsp-tcp" "network-caching=..." "live-caching=..." "-vv" "clock-jitter=..."and "no-audio", "--no-sout-audio" to mute the audio for the picture during the call How to prevent a library from accessing the local network?
1
0
64
1w
Core Motion timing between Apple Watch and iPhone under required reason 35F9.1
We are developing an Apple Watch and iPhone training app and would like guidance on the required-reason API requirements for sharing a timing relationship between the two apps. On Apple Watch, we record Core Motion samples and read ProcessInfo.processInfo.systemUptime when each sample callback arrives. The paired iPhone uses timing information to analyze sample ordering and freshness. The two values relevant to this question are: Measurement timestamp: CMLogItem.timestamp associated with the Core Motion sample on Apple Watch. Callback observation time: systemUptime read by the Watch app when it receives that sample’s callback. The proposed interval is the callback observation time minus the measurement timestamp, calculated on the Watch. Both endpoints are on the Watch. The iPhone is the intended recipient of the interval; its receipt time is not an endpoint of this calculation. For illustration only, synthetic values of 1,000.000 seconds for the measurement timestamp and 1,000.020 seconds for the callback observation time would produce a proposed interval of 0.020 seconds. These are not real measurements. This arithmetic example does not establish clock compatibility or permission to transmit the result. Apple’s documentation describes CMLogItem.timestamp as seconds since device boot. The System Boot Time required-reason API list includes systemUptime and mach_absolute_time(). Reason 35F9.1 permits certain elapsed-time measurements and includes an exception for elapsed time between events that occurred within the app. Our questions are: Is CMLogItem.timestamp itself covered by the System Boot Time required-reason API category? We do not see this property explicitly included in the published list. Under reason 35F9.1, may the interval between a Core Motion measurement timestamp and the app’s callback observation time be sent from Apple Watch to its paired iPhone for analysis? Specifically, does it qualify for the exception for elapsed time between events that occurred within the app, given that the measurement time comes from Core Motion? If not, is there an approved way to represent this timing relationship while preserving sample ordering and freshness analysis? Which timing information may be transferred, and which approved reason, if any, applies? We are not reporting an Apple API malfunction. We are asking how to implement this use in accordance with the privacy requirements. Our focused local Xcode sample uses synthetic values only. It does not collect real motion data or transmit data between devices.
0
0
93
1w
Family Controls: what may leave the device, and does school distribution count as an organizational setting?
Hello, My colleague and I are building a digital wellbeing app for high school students aged 14–17. Students install it on their own iPhones and choose to use it. It is not a covert monitoring or parental control tool. Students set a daily social media goal and earn points for meeting it, which they can redeem for rewards offered by their school. We plan to use FamilyControls with individual authorization, and DeviceActivity. We have read the Family Controls Framework section of the Developer Program License Agreement (section 3.3.3). It says device or usage data may not be shared beyond the individual and their device, and we want to design within it. On-device storage: A DTS reply in another thread (https://developer.apple.com/forums/thread/825822) says device activity data may be used within the device activity target, as long as this doesn't involve storing or manipulating the data. May our DeviceActivityMonitor extension record in an App Group that a threshold was reached, so our main app can show the student their own progress? Derived results: With the student's explicit consent, may the app send our server only a coarse result computed on the device? For example: a. "Goal met" or "goal not met" for the day b. A daily tier, such as "under 1 hour" Does Apple consider either of these "device or usage data"? Redeeming rewards: If neither is allowed, what is the recommended way to let a student redeem a reward based on a result that stays on their device? School distribution: Schools would distribute the app. Staff would see only class-level aggregates, computed on our server from the results in question 2, such as "70% of consenting students met their goal". No individual result is visible to anyone but the student. Would this count as an "organizational setting" under the agreement? If so, which part of the design causes that? Would love some help on these questions, Barak
0
0
61
1w
ATT iOS 27.2 EU – Does the 12-month reprompt interval include decisions made before iOS 27.2?
Hello, We are investigating the new annual ATT reprompting behavior introduced in iOS 27.2 for EU users. Apple's documentation states that developers can request ATT authorization again one year after the user's previous choice. However, we would like to clarify how this applies to existing ATT decisions made before iOS 27.2. Questions Previous ATT decisions older than 12 months If a user denied ATT permission in March 2025 on an earlier iOS version and upgrades to iOS 27.2 in November 2026, can the app immediately display the ATT prompt again? Previous ATT decisions less than 12 months old If a user denied ATT permission in June 2026, will the next ATT prompt become available in June 2027, or does the 12-month period start from the installation of iOS 27.2? Historical ATT decision timestamps Does iOS maintain the original timestamp of ATT decisions made on previous iOS versions, or does the new annual reprompting mechanism only track decisions recorded from iOS 27.2 onwards? Reprompt eligibility API Is there any public API that allows developers to determine whether a user is eligible for an ATT reprompt, without actually attempting to display it? Context This is particularly important for existing applications and Consent Management Platforms (CMPs), where we need to coordinate ATT authorization with GDPR consent flows. Understanding whether the 12-month interval applies retroactively to existing ATT decisions would help us implement the new behavior correctly without unnecessarily prompting users or disrupting existing consent flows. Thank you for your clarification
0
1
134
1w
Sending a user-approved summary derived from HealthKit data to a third-party AI service (Guideline 5.1.3(i), DPLA 3.3.3(H))?
An optional coaching feature in my planned app would, after explicit opt-in, send a short text summary (for example sleep duration or heart rate variability over the last week) to a third-party AI service to generate advice for that same user. The data is not used for advertising, marketing or data mining. Guideline 5.1.3(i) allows disclosure of HealthKit-derived data only "for improving health management, or for the purpose of health research, and then only with permission", and DPLA 3.3.3(H) allows disclosure to a third party only with prior express consent and only to provide health, motion or fitness services. Is a per-user coaching feature like this within what 5.1.3(i) and 3.3.3(H) permit? Does it matter whether the summarised values were entered manually (and stored in HealthKit) or measured by a device? I understand this is not a pre-approval; I would like to know how the rule is meant to be read. Thank you.
0
0
308
1w
Guideline 5.1.3(ii) and DPLA 3.3.3(D): private CloudKit for meal logs and workout logs (no HealthKit values)?
I am planning an iOS app for strength training, nutrition and sleep. Before I build the data layer I would like to understand how Apple reads the following rules. Planned design: Body measurements and sleep values live in HealthKit only and are never written to iCloud or CloudKit. Training sessions and meal entries (food, calories, macronutrients, entered manually or by barcode scan) are stored on the device and in the user's private CloudKit database. Nothing is stored on our own servers. The app also caches packaged food products the user has scanned (name, ingredients, allergens, nutrition facts from the public Open Food Facts database) in the same private CloudKit database. Guideline 5.1.3(ii) says apps "may not store personal health information in iCloud", and DPLA 3.3.3(D) restricts using iCloud or CloudKit for "sensitive, individually-identifiable health information" unless Apple permits it in writing. Questions: Does a meal log or a product cache in the user's private CloudKit database count as "personal health information" in this sense, as long as no HealthKit values are stored there? Is the answer different if the private CloudKit data is end-to-end encrypted (encryptedValues)? I understand that App Review cannot pre-approve an app. I am only asking how the rule is meant to be read. Thank you.
0
0
273
1w
Rejected under 5.1.2(i) for a custom tracking prompt, but the app doesn't track. Looking for guidance
Hi all. I'm a solo developer of an iOS fitness app and I just got rejected under Guideline 5.1.2(i). I'd really appreciate some guidance, because I think I understand the rejection but I'm not sure of the right way to handle it. Here's what App Review said: "The app does not use App Tracking Transparency to request the user's permission before collecting data used to track them. Instead, the app displays a custom prompt that requests the user to allow tracking." The prompt they're talking about is a sheet I show that asks "Share usage data?" and lets the person say yes or no. Nothing is sent to our analytics provider unless they say yes. The reason I'm confused is that I don't think my app tracks anyone by Apple's definition (and a few other posts I saw online say that PostHog doesn't fall under this category). The way I read it, tracking means linking data from my app with other companies' data for targeted advertising or ad measurement, or sharing it with data brokers. My app: - Has no ads and no ad SDKs - Doesn't use the advertising identifier (IDFA) - Doesn't combine user data with other companies' data - Doesn't share data with data brokers - Declares no tracking in its privacy manifest and App Privacy label The prompt is only for product analytics through PostHog, so I can see things like which screens and features get used. Those events are tied to a random account ID. They don't include workout totals, health readings or cycle data. I asked for permission because I thought it was the right thing to do for a health and fitness app, and because Guideline 5.1.2(i) says to get permission before sharing data with third parties. It seems like the prompt may have been read as asking to track, when it's really asking for permission for analytics that aren't tracking. My plan for the resubmission is to remove the prompt, explain that in my notes, and leave a switch in Settings that's off by default. The downside is that almost nobody will ever turn it on, so I'd have very little data on how people use the app. My questions: 1. Is a custom prompt allowed when it asks permission for first-party product analytics and not tracking? Has anyone gotten one approved, and did specific wording or a note to App Review help? 2. If the app really doesn't track, is removing the prompt and explaining that in the review notes the right way to resolve this? 3. Would it be wrong to use the App Tracking Transparency prompt here? My understanding is that it's only for apps that actually track, and using it would wrongly suggest that mine does. 4. Is an off-by-default switch in Settings enough permission for analytics like this? Or is there a better way to ask that App Review is comfortable with? If anyone has been through this, or anyone from Apple can point me in the right direction, I'd really appreciate it. I want to do this the right way. Thanks!
0
0
163
2w
File Provider extension can't reach local network hosts on macOS 27, containing app can
On macOS 27 the File Provider extension of our app (Secure ShellFish, an SSH client) can't connect to any host on the local network, while the containing app connects to the same host on the same Mac without problems. Local Network is enabled for the app in System Settings, but every connection from the extension fails with "Local network prohibited". It did not happen on macOS 26 and still happens on macOS 27.2 (26B123). This is hitting end users of Secure ShellFish, not just my test setup, and it has been my number one support issue since macOS 27 was released. I filed this as FB24999927 with a sysdiagnose. I'm posting here to find out whether others with File Provider (or other) extensions see the same, and whether there is anything on our side that should make it work. Steps Install the app on a clean macOS 27 system and launch it. Choose Allow at the Local Network prompt. Add an SSH server on the local network (another Mac in my test) and open a terminal to it. This works. Open the same server in Finder (the File Provider domain under ~/Library/CloudStorage). The directory listing fails. What happens TN3179 says "In general, app extensions share the Local Network privilege state of their container app", so I expected the listing to load. Instead every connection from the extension to the LAN host is blocked, and the error depends on the networking API: CFStream: ENETDOWN (50) "Network is down" BSD socket connect(): EHOSTUNREACH (65) "No route to host" Network.framework (NWConnection, multipath TCP): waits with path unsatisfied (Local network prohibited) until our connect timeout, ETIMEDOUT (60) No Local Network prompt appears. Toggling the permission, rebooting, killing the extension process and reinstalling the app don't help. What I ruled out A stale extension process: freshly launched extension processes are blocked on their very first connection. A missing UUID cache: after installing a new build, nehelper populates the cache for the app with 14 UUIDs, including both slices of the extension's executable. The extension was blocked 23 seconds later. Shared executable UUIDs: the app and the extension have distinct Mach-O UUIDs. The sandbox: the extension has com.apple.security.network.client. A missing usage string: adding NSLocalNetworkUsageDescription to the extension's Info.plist changed nothing, with no prompt and no separate entry in System Settings. Networking in general: the extension reaches internet hosts and the Mac itself by its local name. Only other hosts on the local network are blocked. Log The blocked notification arrives with bundle_id: (null). UserEventAgent then maps the extension to the app by its UUID, nehelper answers that local network is allowed by preference, and the handler is called with the newly allowed state. Later connections from the same process are still blocked, so that state never takes effect for the extension. 09:19:37.575 UserEventAgent Got local network blocked notification: pid: 4297, uuid: 183484C2-8052-36AD-A81E-B02F15F875B3, bundle_id: (null) 09:19:37.575 UserEventAgent LocalNetwork: found bundle id com.appliedphasor.secure-shellfish.mac-provider by PID 09:19:37.575 ShellFish-Finder [C1.1.1 IPv6#dace0833.22 failed path (unsatisfied (Local network prohibited), interface: en0[802.11], ipv4, ipv6, uses wifi)] 09:19:37.576 UserEventAgent LocalNetwork: found bundle id com.appliedphasor.secure-shellfish by UUID 183484C2-8052-36AD-A81E-B02F15F875B3 09:19:37.597 nehelper UUID cache hit for com.appliedphasor.secure-shellfish 09:19:37.597 nehelper Local network allowed by preference for ShellFish (com.appliedphasor.secure-shellfish) 09:19:37.597 UserEventAgent App got response: 1 09:19:37.597 UserEventAgent Calling handler with newly allowed state: 1 09:19:44.795 fileproviderd populate-directory error: FP -1004 "Unable to list p5.local: Unable To Connect To P5.Local: Network Is Down."Questions Is this a known change in macOS 27? FB24035385 (helper and child processes no longer inherit Local Network access on macOS 27) sounds related, and other File Provider apps report the same, for example nextcloud/desktop#10885: https://github.com/nextcloud/desktop/issues/10885 Does an extension need anything on macOS 27 to share its container's Local Network privilege, such as an entitlement, an Info.plist key, or something the app must do first? If not, is there a supported workaround? The only one we see is to relay the extension's traffic through the main app over loopback, which only works while the app is running. For these users Finder integration is completely broken, because servers on the local network (Raspberry Pi, NAS, home servers) are the most common setup among them. Any pointers are much appreciated.
2
8
404
2w
Does Privacy Manifest reason C617.1 cover fstat on POSIX shared memory?
Our iOS app uses shm_open to create an app-owned, App Group-scoped POSIX shared-memory object. Before allowing access to previously authorized offline data, we call fstat on its file descriptor to verify the object's size, owner UID, and permission mode. We do not access file timestamps, use this information for fingerprinting, or send the metadata off-device. Apple's approved reason C617.1 refers to files inside app or App Group containers. However, POSIX shared-memory objects have no filesystem entry. Does C617.1 cover this specific use of fstat? If not, should we request a new approved reason?
0
0
173
2w
Foundation Models availability in mainland China
Hi, Apple recently announced that Apple Intelligence will launch in mainland China with iOS 27.3. Will the Foundation Models framework also become available to third-party apps in mainland China? If so, will it use the new iOS 27 Apple Foundation Model or an older version? Will the new capabilities and Private Cloud Compute also be supported? Thanks!
2
0
414
2w
ITMS-91055: Invalid API reason declaration
in this weeks i received this error: ITMS-91055: Invalid API reason declaration - The PrivacyInfo.xcprivacy for the “VanigliaPro” file contains “App Functionality” as the value for a NSPrivacyAccessedAPITypeReasons key instead of a valid reason code for using an API in the NSPrivacyAccessedAPICategoryFileTimestamp category. While no action is required at this time, starting May 1, 2024, when you upload a new app or app update, values for NSPrivacyAccessedAPITypeReasons keys in your app’s privacy manifest must be valid reason codes for the corresponding API category. For more details about this policy, including a list of required reason APIs and approved reasons for usage, visit: https://developer.apple.com/documentation/bundleresources/privacy_manifest_files/describing_use_of_required_reason_api. ITMS-91053: Missing API declaration - Your app’s code in the “xxxx” file references one or more APIs that require reasons, including the following API categories: NSPrivacyAccessedAPICategoryUserDefaults. While no action is required at this time, starting May 1, 2024, when you upload a new app or app update, you must include a NSPrivacyAccessedAPITypes array in your app’s privacy manifest to provide approved reasons for these APIs used by your app’s code. For more details about this policy, including a list of required reason APIs and approved reasons for usage, visit: https://developer.apple.com/documentation/bundleresources/privacy_manifest_files/describing_use_of_required_reason_api. ITMS-91053: Missing API declaration - Your app’s code in the “xxxx” file references one or more APIs that require reasons, including the following API categories: NSPrivacyAccessedAPICategoryFileTimestamp. While no action is required at this time, starting May 1, 2024, when you upload a new app or app update, you must include a NSPrivacyAccessedAPITypes array in your app’s privacy manifest to provide approved reasons for these APIs used by your app’s code. For more details about this policy, including a list of required reason APIs and approved reasons for usage, visit: https://developer.apple.com/documentation/bundleresources/privacy_manifest_files/describing_use_of_required_reason_api. any help for make correct privacy file?
2
1
3.2k
3w
Is it possible for a launch daemon to inherit TCC permissions from its enclosing app bundle?
I'm developing an Accessibility-enabled app that includes a helper app registered as a launch daemon using SMAppService. This daemon will connect to HID which requires both being root as well as having Accessibility (or Input Monitoring) permissions. I want this app to have as little friction for the user as I can manage. One friction I'd like to avoid is requiring the user to grant more than one application permission to use Accessibility features. So I'm wondering if I can set up the launch daemon so that it inherits the TCC permissions of its parent bundle. I'll note that the one way I've found that works is to not have the helper app have its own app bundle, but rather just have it be an executable placed alongside the main executable in enclosing bundle's Contents/MacOS directory. This has the disadvantage though of having the helper process and main process have the same name in Activity Monitor, which I think will be confusing to users. So in short, is there a supported way for a bundled application with its own CFBundleName / CFBundleDisplayName key to run as a launch daemon and also inherit Accessibility permissions from its parent app bundle?
7
0
370
3w
Handling ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest
An ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest rejection email looks as follows: ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest- Your app includes "<path/to/SDK>", which includes , an SDK that was identified in the documentation as a privacy-impacting third-party SDK. Starting February 12, 2025, if a new app includes a privacy-impacting SDK, or an app update adds a new privacy-impacting SDK, the SDK must include a privacy manifest file. Please contact the provider of the SDK that includes this file to get an updated SDK version with a privacy manifest. For more details about this policy, including a list of SDKs that are required to include signatures and manifests, visit: https://developer.apple.com/support/third-party-SDK-requirements. Glossary ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest: An email that includes the name and path of privacy-impacting SDK(s) with no privacy manifest files in your app bundle. For more information, see https://developer.apple.com/support/third-party-SDK-requirements. : The specified privacy-impacting SDK that doesn't include a privacy manifest file. If you are the developer of the rejected app, gather the name of the SDK from the email you received from Apple, then contact the SDK's provider for an updated version that includes a valid privacy manifest. After receiving an updated version of the SDK, verify the SDK includes a valid privacy manifest file at the expected location. For more information, see Adding a privacy manifest to your app or third-party SDK. If your app includes a privacy manifest file, make sure the file only describes the privacy practices of your app. Do not add the privacy practices of the SDK to your app's privacy manifest. If the email lists multiple SDKs, repeat the above process for all of them. If you are the developer of an SDK listed in the email, publish an updated version of your SDK that includes a privacy manifest file with valid keys and values. Every privacy-impacting SDK must contain a privacy manifest file that only describes its privacy practices. To learn how to add a valid privacy manifest to your SDK, see the Additional resources section below. Additional resources Privacy manifest files Describing data use in privacy manifests Describing use of required reason API Adding a privacy manifest to your app or third-party SDK TN3182: Adding privacy tracking keys to your privacy manifest TN3183: Adding required reason API entries to your privacy manifest TN3184: Adding data collection details to your privacy manifest TN3181: Debugging an invalid privacy manifest
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
8.2k
Activity
Mar ’25
Privacy Resources
General: Forums topic: Privacy & Security Forums tag: Privacy Developer > Security — This also covers privacy topics. App privacy details on the App Store UIKit > Protecting the User’s Privacy documentation Bundle Resources > Privacy manifest files documentation TN3181 Debugging an invalid privacy manifest technote TN3182 Adding privacy tracking keys to your privacy manifest technote TN3183 Adding required reason API entries to your privacy manifest technote TN3184 Adding data collection details to your privacy manifest technote TN3179 Understanding local network privacy technote Handling ITMS-91061: Missing privacy manifest forums post Share and Enjoy — Quinn “The Eskimo!” @ Developer Technical Support @ Apple let myEmail = "eskimo" + "1" + "@" + "apple.com"
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
710
Activity
Jul ’25
Screen Recording permission popup not shown & app not added to app list in Screen Recording settings
Requesting the Screen Recording permission seems broken on macOS 27.3 beta 2. I'd love to know whether this change is intentional or whether we can expect a fix before the stable macOS 27.3 release. Feedback report: FB25646769 Behavior until macOS 27.2 When an app calls CGRequestScreenCaptureAccess(), macOS shows the following popup: Additionally, the app is added to the app list in the “Screen & System Audio Recording” panel in the System Settings. It is toggled off by default and the user can easily toggle it on. Behavior on macOS 27.3 beta 2 When an app calls CGRequestScreenCaptureAccess(), no popup appears and the app is not added to the app list in the “Screen & System Audio Recording” panel in the System Settings. The user cannot easily grant the permission. What the user has to do to grant the permission on macOS 27.3 beta 2 It is not intuitive for the user to figure out how to grant the Screen Recording permission. Without any guidance, the user needs to: Click the little plus icon below the app list in the "Screen & System Audio Recording” panel in the System Settings Because the System Settings panel shows two app lists, the user needs to click the plus icon below the correct app list ("Screen & System Audio Recording", not "System Audio Recording Only") Find the app in the file picker and add it This is cumbersome and unintuitive. There's no explanation of what to do. The average user will be confused and will struggle to complete these tasks. Reproduction steps Install an app that requests the Screen Recording permission (e.g., Cap) Get to the onboarding step that requests the Screen Recording permission Observe that the permission request popup is not shown and that the app is not added to the System Settings panel
Replies
3
Boosts
1
Views
140
Activity
1d
Reading Mouse Events with CGEvent tap from a background app in macOS 27.3
WIth macOS 27.3 (beta 2) things have changed quite a bit for security, see Updates to Device Control and Data Access, and Full Disk Access in macOS I have an app which uses what (used to be called) the Privacy & Security / Accessibility permissions in order to receive mouse events in the background to read them and occasionally modify them. The method used: The app checks AXIsProcessTrustedWithOptions to see if it has permission. If it doesn't have permission, it uses the kAXTrustedCheckOptionPrompt option which would open up the privacy & Security / Accessibility pane. Because that process has been a little flakey in macOS, my app has a backup option, where it runs 'open "x-apple.systempreferences:com.apple.settings.PrivacySecurity.extension?Privacy_Accessibility"' and then walks the user through the steps with onscreen instructions. When permission is granted, the app creates a CGEvent tap SessionEvent tap using the HeadInsertEvent option to receive mouse and touch mouse events. See CGEvent.tapCreate In macOS 27.3 beta 2, always returns false using kAXTrustedCheckOptionPrompt fails to do anything open "x-apple.systempreferences:com.apple.settings.PrivacySecurity.extension?Privacy_Accessibility fails to do anything. CGEvent tap fails A few questions: will my third party app be allowed to use CGEventTaps to read mouse and touchpad events? Or has this been cut off completely and only available to first party apps? If it is allowed, how? Has the permission for this moved to a different System Preference pane? is a CGEvent tap the way to do it? I totally understand that security is important, and apps should not have wide-ranging permissions. I'd love to find a way to keep my app running with the minimal permissions needed.
Replies
5
Boosts
0
Views
515
Activity
2d
ATT prompt not shown and status stays notDetermined: how do you handle it?
Hello, our Unity game (iOS/iPadOS) requests App Tracking Transparency on its first scene, before ads are initialized. Background App Review rejected an earlier build under Guideline 2.1(a) for a blank screen on iPad Air 11-inch (M3), iPadOS 27.0. In that build we called requestTrackingAuthorization right at launch and then waited until trackingAuthorizationStatus was no longer .notDetermined. The status never changed, so the app never left the first screen. Current flow (this build was approved) Wait until UIApplication.shared.applicationState == .active and the app has focus. Call requestTrackingAuthorization(completionHandler:) once and wait for the completion handler. If the completion returns .notDetermined, wait about 4 seconds while the app stays active, then call it one more time. Wait until the status is no longer .notDetermined before loading the next scene. There is no timeout. The first scene runs on every cold launch, so if the status is still .notDetermined, the request is made again on the next launch. [ATTrackingManager requestTrackingAuthorizationWithCompletionHandler:^(ATTrackingManagerAuthorizationStatus status) { dispatch_async(dispatch_get_main_queue(), ^{ // store status; Unity polls it on the main thread }); }];We have not been able to reproduce the original problem on our own devices. Questions for those who have shipped apps with ATT How many times do you retry requestTrackingAuthorization, and how long do you wait between attempts? Is there any limit you know of? If the status still stays .notDetermined after retrying, do you let the user continue and treat it as not authorized (no IDFA), or keep waiting? If you wait, how long before you let the user continue? If you continue without tracking, did App Review ever flag that? Any experience or pointers to documentation would be appreciated.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
31
Activity
2d
macOS 27: Accessibility granted via MDM doesn’t cover PostEvent, and leaves a stray TCC managed_overrides row after unenrollment
Our app uses an active CGEventTap (kCGEventTapOptionDefault, mouse down/up events) and relies on the Accessibility permission (Device Control & Data Access). CGEventTapCreate(kCGAnnotatedSessionEventTap, kCGHeadInsertEventTap, kCGEventTapOptionDefault, CGEventMaskBit(kCGEventLeftMouseDown) | CGEventMaskBit(kCGEventLeftMouseUp) | CGEventMaskBit(kCGEventRightMouseDown) | CGEventMaskBit(kCGEventRightMouseUp) | CGEventMaskBit(kCGEventOtherMouseDown) | CGEventMaskBit(kCGEventOtherMouseUp), callback, refcon);On macOS 27.0.1 we see two behaviours when that permission comes from MDM, and we’d like to know whether they’re expected. According to the PrivacyPreferencesPolicyControl.Services documentation, the PPPC Accessibility key is deprecated in macOS 27. It’s replaced by the Privacy → PermissionDefaults setting in the declarative configuration com.apple.configuration.app.settings, and the managed value is a default that the user can change. We tested both the PPPC payload and the DDM configuration. 1. Managed Accessibility grant doesn’t cover PostEvent When the user turns on Accessibility manually in System Settings > Privacy & Security > Accessibility, the event tap works with no further prompts. When Accessibility comes from device management (a PPPC payload or DDM PermissionDefaults): AXIsProcessTrusted() returns true. On the first click through the tap, macOS shows the “control this computer” prompt. tccd adds an access row for kTCCServicePostEvent with auth_value 0 and auth_reason 4. At the same moment, the app’s Accessibility toggle in System Settings switches off. The managed Accessibility row remains auth_value 2, auth_reason 6. After the user accepts the prompt, PostEvent changes to auth_value 2 and the tap works from then on. Questions : Why does a manual Accessibility grant cover an active event tap, while a managed Accessibility default needs a separate PostEvent grant? With PPPC Accessibility deprecated, is DDM Accessibility plus PPPC PostEvent (Allowed) the intended configuration for apps that install active event taps? 2. Stray managed_overrides row after unenrollment On macOS 27, the managed Accessibility value is stored in a new managed_overrides table in /Library/Application Support/com.apple.TCC/TCC.db (schema version 36). On macOS 15 and 26, managed grants were kept in MDMOverrides.plist, and this table doesn’t exist there. Steps : Enroll a never-managed Mac in MDM with user-approved enrollment. Install a profile that grants Accessibility to our app. tccd logs ManagedSettings: inserted managed_overrides for kTCCServiceAccessibility:<bundle id> admin_auth_value=2 auth_value=2. The row is written with policy_id NULL, and policies and active_policy stay empty. Remove the MDM profile from System Settings > General > Device Management. What happens: mdmclient removes the MDM profile first. Removing each TCC payload after that fails with : PlugIn: DetermineUninstallFlags [TCCProfileService] Error: Error Domain=NSPOSIXErrorDomain Code=13 "Permission denied" UserInfo={NSLocalizedDescription=The profile must originate from a user-approved MDM server.}The profiles disappear, MDMOverrides.plist is deleted, and profiles status reports no MDM enrollment. The row remains, with auth_value 1, auth_reason 6 (MDM Policy), policy_id NULL, admin_auth_value 2 and flags 480. tccutil reset Accessibility <bundle id> clears flags but doesn’t remove the row. Later permission prompts and System Settings toggles for the app write to this row instead of to access. Why does the row stay after unenrollment? Is there a supported way to clear it?
Replies
2
Boosts
1
Views
238
Activity
2d
macOS 27.3 Accessibility Entitlements
I saw that Apple announced they intend to only notarize applications with the upcoming accessibility entitlement (macOS 27.3) if those applications provide assistive technologies. Would a tool that records meetings and uses the accessibility API to access meeting metadata (participant names, speaker labels, etc) qualify for this? What are the criteria that Apple are evaluating against to determine eligibility for this entitlement?
Replies
1
Boosts
2
Views
244
Activity
2d
Network Extension URL Filter registration pending review for more than a month
Hello, I am writing about a Network Extension URL Filter configuration submitted through the Identity & Trust section of the CloudKit Console on 5 September 2026 Status shown: In Review / Waiting for Approval Last Modified: 5 September 2026 (unchanged since submission) It has now been 37 days with no response — no approval, no rejection, and no request for changes. The PIR server , Privacy Pass issuer and HTTP/2 OHTTP gateway have been live and serving since the day of submission, configured per the Onboarding.md guidance in Apple's PIR service example, including the apple-url-filter DNS TXT record on the service URL and the url-filter-test validation entry. Could anyone please let me know: Whether this configuration is actually in a review queue, and the expected timeframe; Whether anything further is required from our side — if so, we will act on it the same day. The URL filter is a core protection feature of our app, which is currently in App Store review; the feature stays disabled for users until this registration is approved, so the delay is holding up what we can ship. Thank you for your help.
Replies
5
Boosts
0
Views
319
Activity
2d
Full Disk Access on macOS 27.3
I'm looking into the changes being implemented and I find this way of handling by Apple on short notice problematic. Now our customers (those that don't have MDM) will have to jump through hoops to enable FDA for our product, a security product that also uses Endpoint Security. We already have the entitlement for endpoint security, which requires FDA in order to work, so why make it so difficult instead of just allowing FDA for apps that have this entitlement? Why only backup applications are exempted?
Replies
2
Boosts
0
Views
130
Activity
3d
Local Network Privacy Child Process Behavior
I have a Java Swing application that is bundled into an app bundle using jpackage. The app basically launches a newer version of itself, when there is a new version downloaded in the users installation directory. I have noticed a regression or change in behavior with how LocalNetwork privacy works now. Previously, we would launch our Java application using the .app bundle. This is a launcher that checks for updates and will launch another JVM instance using any new jars it downloads when updating. So, it is closing the original process and spawning a new process using the downloaded jar. The new process is where the app connects to a server on the Local Network. This new process cannot access the Local Network even when the entry in privacy and security is enabled for the parent process. I have changed the behavior of my launcher application so that it keeps the process alive after launching the client application. When doing this, Local Network access works. So, my question is: is it required for the parent process to be running in order for a child process to have Local Network access? In previous macOS versions, this was not an issue, so something has changed with Local Network security across all the latest versions 26 and 27.
Replies
8
Boosts
0
Views
256
Activity
5d
MobileVLCKit (3.7.3) triggering Local Network permission
The problem manifests itself from 16 to 18 iOS not inclusive Versions from 18 up to and including do not cause this problem. When initializing the player, a request for permission to use the local network appears. The application does not use a local network as a capability, even in plist there is no such key. Apple has granted permission to use multicast networking, and the corresponding capability has also been added. The player is assembled as let player = VLCMediaPlayer() player.media = mediaHaving previously collected media with the options "clock-synchro=..." "avcodec-threads=..." "rtsp-tcp" "network-caching=..." "live-caching=..." "-vv" "clock-jitter=..."and "no-audio", "--no-sout-audio" to mute the audio for the picture during the call How to prevent a library from accessing the local network?
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
64
Activity
1w
Core Motion timing between Apple Watch and iPhone under required reason 35F9.1
We are developing an Apple Watch and iPhone training app and would like guidance on the required-reason API requirements for sharing a timing relationship between the two apps. On Apple Watch, we record Core Motion samples and read ProcessInfo.processInfo.systemUptime when each sample callback arrives. The paired iPhone uses timing information to analyze sample ordering and freshness. The two values relevant to this question are: Measurement timestamp: CMLogItem.timestamp associated with the Core Motion sample on Apple Watch. Callback observation time: systemUptime read by the Watch app when it receives that sample’s callback. The proposed interval is the callback observation time minus the measurement timestamp, calculated on the Watch. Both endpoints are on the Watch. The iPhone is the intended recipient of the interval; its receipt time is not an endpoint of this calculation. For illustration only, synthetic values of 1,000.000 seconds for the measurement timestamp and 1,000.020 seconds for the callback observation time would produce a proposed interval of 0.020 seconds. These are not real measurements. This arithmetic example does not establish clock compatibility or permission to transmit the result. Apple’s documentation describes CMLogItem.timestamp as seconds since device boot. The System Boot Time required-reason API list includes systemUptime and mach_absolute_time(). Reason 35F9.1 permits certain elapsed-time measurements and includes an exception for elapsed time between events that occurred within the app. Our questions are: Is CMLogItem.timestamp itself covered by the System Boot Time required-reason API category? We do not see this property explicitly included in the published list. Under reason 35F9.1, may the interval between a Core Motion measurement timestamp and the app’s callback observation time be sent from Apple Watch to its paired iPhone for analysis? Specifically, does it qualify for the exception for elapsed time between events that occurred within the app, given that the measurement time comes from Core Motion? If not, is there an approved way to represent this timing relationship while preserving sample ordering and freshness analysis? Which timing information may be transferred, and which approved reason, if any, applies? We are not reporting an Apple API malfunction. We are asking how to implement this use in accordance with the privacy requirements. Our focused local Xcode sample uses synthetic values only. It does not collect real motion data or transmit data between devices.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
93
Activity
1w
Family Controls: what may leave the device, and does school distribution count as an organizational setting?
Hello, My colleague and I are building a digital wellbeing app for high school students aged 14–17. Students install it on their own iPhones and choose to use it. It is not a covert monitoring or parental control tool. Students set a daily social media goal and earn points for meeting it, which they can redeem for rewards offered by their school. We plan to use FamilyControls with individual authorization, and DeviceActivity. We have read the Family Controls Framework section of the Developer Program License Agreement (section 3.3.3). It says device or usage data may not be shared beyond the individual and their device, and we want to design within it. On-device storage: A DTS reply in another thread (https://developer.apple.com/forums/thread/825822) says device activity data may be used within the device activity target, as long as this doesn't involve storing or manipulating the data. May our DeviceActivityMonitor extension record in an App Group that a threshold was reached, so our main app can show the student their own progress? Derived results: With the student's explicit consent, may the app send our server only a coarse result computed on the device? For example: a. "Goal met" or "goal not met" for the day b. A daily tier, such as "under 1 hour" Does Apple consider either of these "device or usage data"? Redeeming rewards: If neither is allowed, what is the recommended way to let a student redeem a reward based on a result that stays on their device? School distribution: Schools would distribute the app. Staff would see only class-level aggregates, computed on our server from the results in question 2, such as "70% of consenting students met their goal". No individual result is visible to anyone but the student. Would this count as an "organizational setting" under the agreement? If so, which part of the design causes that? Would love some help on these questions, Barak
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
61
Activity
1w
ATT iOS 27.2 EU – Does the 12-month reprompt interval include decisions made before iOS 27.2?
Hello, We are investigating the new annual ATT reprompting behavior introduced in iOS 27.2 for EU users. Apple's documentation states that developers can request ATT authorization again one year after the user's previous choice. However, we would like to clarify how this applies to existing ATT decisions made before iOS 27.2. Questions Previous ATT decisions older than 12 months If a user denied ATT permission in March 2025 on an earlier iOS version and upgrades to iOS 27.2 in November 2026, can the app immediately display the ATT prompt again? Previous ATT decisions less than 12 months old If a user denied ATT permission in June 2026, will the next ATT prompt become available in June 2027, or does the 12-month period start from the installation of iOS 27.2? Historical ATT decision timestamps Does iOS maintain the original timestamp of ATT decisions made on previous iOS versions, or does the new annual reprompting mechanism only track decisions recorded from iOS 27.2 onwards? Reprompt eligibility API Is there any public API that allows developers to determine whether a user is eligible for an ATT reprompt, without actually attempting to display it? Context This is particularly important for existing applications and Consent Management Platforms (CMPs), where we need to coordinate ATT authorization with GDPR consent flows. Understanding whether the 12-month interval applies retroactively to existing ATT decisions would help us implement the new behavior correctly without unnecessarily prompting users or disrupting existing consent flows. Thank you for your clarification
Replies
0
Boosts
1
Views
134
Activity
1w
Sending a user-approved summary derived from HealthKit data to a third-party AI service (Guideline 5.1.3(i), DPLA 3.3.3(H))?
An optional coaching feature in my planned app would, after explicit opt-in, send a short text summary (for example sleep duration or heart rate variability over the last week) to a third-party AI service to generate advice for that same user. The data is not used for advertising, marketing or data mining. Guideline 5.1.3(i) allows disclosure of HealthKit-derived data only "for improving health management, or for the purpose of health research, and then only with permission", and DPLA 3.3.3(H) allows disclosure to a third party only with prior express consent and only to provide health, motion or fitness services. Is a per-user coaching feature like this within what 5.1.3(i) and 3.3.3(H) permit? Does it matter whether the summarised values were entered manually (and stored in HealthKit) or measured by a device? I understand this is not a pre-approval; I would like to know how the rule is meant to be read. Thank you.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
308
Activity
1w
Guideline 5.1.3(ii) and DPLA 3.3.3(D): private CloudKit for meal logs and workout logs (no HealthKit values)?
I am planning an iOS app for strength training, nutrition and sleep. Before I build the data layer I would like to understand how Apple reads the following rules. Planned design: Body measurements and sleep values live in HealthKit only and are never written to iCloud or CloudKit. Training sessions and meal entries (food, calories, macronutrients, entered manually or by barcode scan) are stored on the device and in the user's private CloudKit database. Nothing is stored on our own servers. The app also caches packaged food products the user has scanned (name, ingredients, allergens, nutrition facts from the public Open Food Facts database) in the same private CloudKit database. Guideline 5.1.3(ii) says apps "may not store personal health information in iCloud", and DPLA 3.3.3(D) restricts using iCloud or CloudKit for "sensitive, individually-identifiable health information" unless Apple permits it in writing. Questions: Does a meal log or a product cache in the user's private CloudKit database count as "personal health information" in this sense, as long as no HealthKit values are stored there? Is the answer different if the private CloudKit data is end-to-end encrypted (encryptedValues)? I understand that App Review cannot pre-approve an app. I am only asking how the rule is meant to be read. Thank you.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
273
Activity
1w
Rejected under 5.1.2(i) for a custom tracking prompt, but the app doesn't track. Looking for guidance
Hi all. I'm a solo developer of an iOS fitness app and I just got rejected under Guideline 5.1.2(i). I'd really appreciate some guidance, because I think I understand the rejection but I'm not sure of the right way to handle it. Here's what App Review said: "The app does not use App Tracking Transparency to request the user's permission before collecting data used to track them. Instead, the app displays a custom prompt that requests the user to allow tracking." The prompt they're talking about is a sheet I show that asks "Share usage data?" and lets the person say yes or no. Nothing is sent to our analytics provider unless they say yes. The reason I'm confused is that I don't think my app tracks anyone by Apple's definition (and a few other posts I saw online say that PostHog doesn't fall under this category). The way I read it, tracking means linking data from my app with other companies' data for targeted advertising or ad measurement, or sharing it with data brokers. My app: - Has no ads and no ad SDKs - Doesn't use the advertising identifier (IDFA) - Doesn't combine user data with other companies' data - Doesn't share data with data brokers - Declares no tracking in its privacy manifest and App Privacy label The prompt is only for product analytics through PostHog, so I can see things like which screens and features get used. Those events are tied to a random account ID. They don't include workout totals, health readings or cycle data. I asked for permission because I thought it was the right thing to do for a health and fitness app, and because Guideline 5.1.2(i) says to get permission before sharing data with third parties. It seems like the prompt may have been read as asking to track, when it's really asking for permission for analytics that aren't tracking. My plan for the resubmission is to remove the prompt, explain that in my notes, and leave a switch in Settings that's off by default. The downside is that almost nobody will ever turn it on, so I'd have very little data on how people use the app. My questions: 1. Is a custom prompt allowed when it asks permission for first-party product analytics and not tracking? Has anyone gotten one approved, and did specific wording or a note to App Review help? 2. If the app really doesn't track, is removing the prompt and explaining that in the review notes the right way to resolve this? 3. Would it be wrong to use the App Tracking Transparency prompt here? My understanding is that it's only for apps that actually track, and using it would wrongly suggest that mine does. 4. Is an off-by-default switch in Settings enough permission for analytics like this? Or is there a better way to ask that App Review is comfortable with? If anyone has been through this, or anyone from Apple can point me in the right direction, I'd really appreciate it. I want to do this the right way. Thanks!
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
163
Activity
2w
File Provider extension can't reach local network hosts on macOS 27, containing app can
On macOS 27 the File Provider extension of our app (Secure ShellFish, an SSH client) can't connect to any host on the local network, while the containing app connects to the same host on the same Mac without problems. Local Network is enabled for the app in System Settings, but every connection from the extension fails with "Local network prohibited". It did not happen on macOS 26 and still happens on macOS 27.2 (26B123). This is hitting end users of Secure ShellFish, not just my test setup, and it has been my number one support issue since macOS 27 was released. I filed this as FB24999927 with a sysdiagnose. I'm posting here to find out whether others with File Provider (or other) extensions see the same, and whether there is anything on our side that should make it work. Steps Install the app on a clean macOS 27 system and launch it. Choose Allow at the Local Network prompt. Add an SSH server on the local network (another Mac in my test) and open a terminal to it. This works. Open the same server in Finder (the File Provider domain under ~/Library/CloudStorage). The directory listing fails. What happens TN3179 says "In general, app extensions share the Local Network privilege state of their container app", so I expected the listing to load. Instead every connection from the extension to the LAN host is blocked, and the error depends on the networking API: CFStream: ENETDOWN (50) "Network is down" BSD socket connect(): EHOSTUNREACH (65) "No route to host" Network.framework (NWConnection, multipath TCP): waits with path unsatisfied (Local network prohibited) until our connect timeout, ETIMEDOUT (60) No Local Network prompt appears. Toggling the permission, rebooting, killing the extension process and reinstalling the app don't help. What I ruled out A stale extension process: freshly launched extension processes are blocked on their very first connection. A missing UUID cache: after installing a new build, nehelper populates the cache for the app with 14 UUIDs, including both slices of the extension's executable. The extension was blocked 23 seconds later. Shared executable UUIDs: the app and the extension have distinct Mach-O UUIDs. The sandbox: the extension has com.apple.security.network.client. A missing usage string: adding NSLocalNetworkUsageDescription to the extension's Info.plist changed nothing, with no prompt and no separate entry in System Settings. Networking in general: the extension reaches internet hosts and the Mac itself by its local name. Only other hosts on the local network are blocked. Log The blocked notification arrives with bundle_id: (null). UserEventAgent then maps the extension to the app by its UUID, nehelper answers that local network is allowed by preference, and the handler is called with the newly allowed state. Later connections from the same process are still blocked, so that state never takes effect for the extension. 09:19:37.575 UserEventAgent Got local network blocked notification: pid: 4297, uuid: 183484C2-8052-36AD-A81E-B02F15F875B3, bundle_id: (null) 09:19:37.575 UserEventAgent LocalNetwork: found bundle id com.appliedphasor.secure-shellfish.mac-provider by PID 09:19:37.575 ShellFish-Finder [C1.1.1 IPv6#dace0833.22 failed path (unsatisfied (Local network prohibited), interface: en0[802.11], ipv4, ipv6, uses wifi)] 09:19:37.576 UserEventAgent LocalNetwork: found bundle id com.appliedphasor.secure-shellfish by UUID 183484C2-8052-36AD-A81E-B02F15F875B3 09:19:37.597 nehelper UUID cache hit for com.appliedphasor.secure-shellfish 09:19:37.597 nehelper Local network allowed by preference for ShellFish (com.appliedphasor.secure-shellfish) 09:19:37.597 UserEventAgent App got response: 1 09:19:37.597 UserEventAgent Calling handler with newly allowed state: 1 09:19:44.795 fileproviderd populate-directory error: FP -1004 "Unable to list p5.local: Unable To Connect To P5.Local: Network Is Down."Questions Is this a known change in macOS 27? FB24035385 (helper and child processes no longer inherit Local Network access on macOS 27) sounds related, and other File Provider apps report the same, for example nextcloud/desktop#10885: https://github.com/nextcloud/desktop/issues/10885 Does an extension need anything on macOS 27 to share its container's Local Network privilege, such as an entitlement, an Info.plist key, or something the app must do first? If not, is there a supported workaround? The only one we see is to relay the extension's traffic through the main app over loopback, which only works while the app is running. For these users Finder integration is completely broken, because servers on the local network (Raspberry Pi, NAS, home servers) are the most common setup among them. Any pointers are much appreciated.
Replies
2
Boosts
8
Views
404
Activity
2w
Does Privacy Manifest reason C617.1 cover fstat on POSIX shared memory?
Our iOS app uses shm_open to create an app-owned, App Group-scoped POSIX shared-memory object. Before allowing access to previously authorized offline data, we call fstat on its file descriptor to verify the object's size, owner UID, and permission mode. We do not access file timestamps, use this information for fingerprinting, or send the metadata off-device. Apple's approved reason C617.1 refers to files inside app or App Group containers. However, POSIX shared-memory objects have no filesystem entry. Does C617.1 cover this specific use of fstat? If not, should we request a new approved reason?
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
173
Activity
2w
Foundation Models availability in mainland China
Hi, Apple recently announced that Apple Intelligence will launch in mainland China with iOS 27.3. Will the Foundation Models framework also become available to third-party apps in mainland China? If so, will it use the new iOS 27 Apple Foundation Model or an older version? Will the new capabilities and Private Cloud Compute also be supported? Thanks!
Replies
2
Boosts
0
Views
414
Activity
2w
ITMS-91055: Invalid API reason declaration
in this weeks i received this error: ITMS-91055: Invalid API reason declaration - The PrivacyInfo.xcprivacy for the “VanigliaPro” file contains “App Functionality” as the value for a NSPrivacyAccessedAPITypeReasons key instead of a valid reason code for using an API in the NSPrivacyAccessedAPICategoryFileTimestamp category. While no action is required at this time, starting May 1, 2024, when you upload a new app or app update, values for NSPrivacyAccessedAPITypeReasons keys in your app’s privacy manifest must be valid reason codes for the corresponding API category. For more details about this policy, including a list of required reason APIs and approved reasons for usage, visit: https://developer.apple.com/documentation/bundleresources/privacy_manifest_files/describing_use_of_required_reason_api. ITMS-91053: Missing API declaration - Your app’s code in the “xxxx” file references one or more APIs that require reasons, including the following API categories: NSPrivacyAccessedAPICategoryUserDefaults. While no action is required at this time, starting May 1, 2024, when you upload a new app or app update, you must include a NSPrivacyAccessedAPITypes array in your app’s privacy manifest to provide approved reasons for these APIs used by your app’s code. For more details about this policy, including a list of required reason APIs and approved reasons for usage, visit: https://developer.apple.com/documentation/bundleresources/privacy_manifest_files/describing_use_of_required_reason_api. ITMS-91053: Missing API declaration - Your app’s code in the “xxxx” file references one or more APIs that require reasons, including the following API categories: NSPrivacyAccessedAPICategoryFileTimestamp. While no action is required at this time, starting May 1, 2024, when you upload a new app or app update, you must include a NSPrivacyAccessedAPITypes array in your app’s privacy manifest to provide approved reasons for these APIs used by your app’s code. For more details about this policy, including a list of required reason APIs and approved reasons for usage, visit: https://developer.apple.com/documentation/bundleresources/privacy_manifest_files/describing_use_of_required_reason_api. any help for make correct privacy file?
Replies
2
Boosts
1
Views
3.2k
Activity
3w
Is it possible for a launch daemon to inherit TCC permissions from its enclosing app bundle?
I'm developing an Accessibility-enabled app that includes a helper app registered as a launch daemon using SMAppService. This daemon will connect to HID which requires both being root as well as having Accessibility (or Input Monitoring) permissions. I want this app to have as little friction for the user as I can manage. One friction I'd like to avoid is requiring the user to grant more than one application permission to use Accessibility features. So I'm wondering if I can set up the launch daemon so that it inherits the TCC permissions of its parent bundle. I'll note that the one way I've found that works is to not have the helper app have its own app bundle, but rather just have it be an executable placed alongside the main executable in enclosing bundle's Contents/MacOS directory. This has the disadvantage though of having the helper process and main process have the same name in Activity Monitor, which I think will be confusing to users. So in short, is there a supported way for a bundled application with its own CFBundleName / CFBundleDisplayName key to run as a launch daemon and also inherit Accessibility permissions from its parent app bundle?
Replies
7
Boosts
0
Views
370
Activity
3w