New App Rejected Under Guideline 4.3(a) on Both iOS and tvOS — Seeking Clarification

Hi everyone,

I’d like to share my experience with the first release of my app and ask for some guidance.

Submission details

  • App ID: 6829444660
  • Platforms: iOS and tvOS (Apple TV)
  • Initially submitted: November 1, 2026, at 7:17 PM
  • Rejection received: November 13, 2026, at 9:30 PM
  • Rejection reason: Guideline 4.3(a) — Design — Spam

Both the iOS and Apple TV submissions received the same rejection at the same time.

How the app was built

I personally developed the app using UIKit, with some parts built in SwiftUI. I also created the visual assets myself using Canva.

AI was not involved in writing or designing the app; its involvement was limited to testing-related assistance.

Having personally worked on the implementation and visual design, it was discouraging to see the app classified as spam. I believe there may be a misunderstanding about my submission, and I would appreciate an opportunity to clarify it.

What I’m asking for

Could an Apple representative help identify the specific elements or duplication concerns that led to this rejection?

Clear, actionable feedback would help me understand:

  • Which aspects of the app raised concerns under Guideline 4.3(a).
  • What changes, if any, are needed to address those concerns.
  • What supporting information I can provide to help clarify the situation.

This project means a lot to me. I respect the review process and want to meet Apple’s requirements. I would sincerely appreciate a reconsideration of my submission and clear guidance on how to move forward.

Has anyone experienced a simultaneous 4.3(a) rejection on iOS and tvOS and successfully resolved it?

Thank you for taking the time to read this. Any guidance would mean a great deal to me.

Which aspects of the app raised concerns under Guideline 4.3(a).

The explanation for them to have been both rejected is probably explained by the following statement.

Both the iOS and Apple TV submissions received the same rejection at the same time.

There isn't much that you can do about it. If you reply under Resolution Center, you will be greeted by their spam bot. If you file an appeal, they may reject them after waiting for 2 to 3 weeks. The appeal board now uses the same spam bot to reject multiple cases at a time. If you are lucky, they make take a very good at your cases individually.

15 years ago, the appeal board was quite neutral. Nowadadays, their spam bot screws things up a big time.

4.3(a) is frustrating because the message never says what your app was compared to. It doesn't mean Apple thinks you didn't build it yourself: it means their checks found your binary, metadata or concept close to apps from other developers. They look at all three together.

A few things worth checking in your case:

  • Canva assets. If your icon or screenshots started from Canva templates, the same layouts are used by thousands of other listings. That alone can match your metadata to other apps. Redoing the icon and the first two screenshots from scratch is worth it.
  • Name and subtitle. A generic name in a crowded category reads as "one more of the same".
  • One app, not two. Make sure iOS and tvOS are the same app record in App Store Connect (one bundle ID, both platforms), not two separate apps. Two records for the same app is exactly what 4.3(a) targets.
  • First screens. The reviewer spends a few minutes in the app. What makes yours different should be visible on the first screen, not three taps deep.

When you reply in App Store Connect, skip how the app was built (Apple judges the result, not the process) and be concrete: who it's for, the 2-3 things it does that similar apps don't, what you changed since the rejection, and how to see it.

I wrote a longer breakdown of 4.3 with a reply template here, in case it helps: https://launchray.app/rejections/app-store-guideline-4-3-spam/?utm_source=apple_forums
(Disclosure: I build Launchray, a tool that checks apps against these rules before submission.)