My iOS app has finally been approved!
App Name: Helmet Horizon
App ID: 6757309236
Category: Games
Platform: iOS (iPhone and iPad), first app on this developer account
Version: 1.0 (13)
Complete review timeline:
- Oct 18, 10:24 PM — First submitted
- Oct 20, 6:45 AM — In Review, then rejected
- Oct 20, 3:18 PM — Resubmitted
- Oct 22, 9:23 AM — In Review
- Oct 22, 10:31 AM — Rejected
- Oct 22, 1:14 PM — Resubmitted
- Oct 26 — Withdrew the submission and submitted a new build
- Nov 8, 11:27 AM — In Review after almost 13 days
- Nov 8, 11:46 AM — Rejected
- Nov 8, 6:08 PM — Resubmitted
- Nov 21, 12:29 AM — In Review after another 12 days
- Nov 21, 12:40 AM — Approved / Pending Developer Release
Total time from the first submission to approval: a little over 33 days.
The actual reviews were generally very quick. The overwhelming majority of the time was spent in “Waiting for Review.”
I never requested an expedited review or contacted Apple Developer Support during the process.
I had attached a detailed demonstration video to the Review Notes. It showed the core gameplay, all menu sections, and exactly where every in-app purchase product could be found. It also opened the Apple purchase confirmation sheet, but did not show a completed sandbox transaction.
I had also explained the navigation in the Review Notes, and each individual in-app purchase product entry in App Store Connect included a description and screenshot showing where that product appeared in the app.
Despite all of this information, the reviewer reported that certain products could not be found. Some products were located outside the main Store menu, and the screenshot attached to the rejection suggested that the reviewer was looking for them only in that menu.
Apple then requested a video showing a complete sandbox purchase flow. I provided a more explicit video that showed how to reach every product and completed the entire sandbox transaction from beginning to end.
My takeaway: especially for a first app, the review video should leave nothing open to interpretation. It should clearly show where every product can be found and include the complete sandbox purchase flow, even when the same information is already provided in the Review Notes and the individual in-app purchase product entries.
I’m very happy and relieved that the app has finally made it onto the App Store (currently in soft launch, with the worldwide release to follow).
Good luck to everyone who is still waiting!