All my new apps were rejected for SPAM instantly - Guideline 4.3

Hello!
I already have 4 active apps and 2 games in the App Store.

THE PROBLEM
In past months I've submitted a few new apps and games, all of which were instantly rejected under guideline 4.3 regarding spam.
They went from “Waiting for Review” to “In Review” and, a second later, to “Rejected.”
This happenend to all 4 new apps I was submitting.
I answered all the questions, but I don't think they were ever read, since all apps were rejected immediately again.

I can't share my apps/games with you via TestFlight either, because they get rejected there as well.
I can only give you Play Store links if your are interested, or let you play desktop demos for the games.

I believe there is no need to say that I have been working on these apps and games for several months and that, for the most part, they are original and in no way copies of anything else. Some of their features are actually unique, or at least not found in comparable apps.

For example, one of these apps is an advanced expiry tracker with integrated AI scanning and management capabilities, with a strong focus on privacy, which can effortlessly handle all types of expiration with minimal user input (automatic renewal, aumatic expense management, and so on).

Another game I've been working on for a long time is a complete motorcycle racing suite called the Hyper Racing Series, featuring 3 games in one: superbike racing, supermoto racing, MX racing. Each game has its own physics and control system, unique motorcycle models, unique tracks. The engine sounds were synthesized based on the sounds of real racing motorcycles.

One of these app already is doing well on the Play Store, and people who have downloaded it have left positive reviews, and some of them are using the premium features as well.

WHAT TO DO NOW?
So, what would you guys do if you were in my shoes at this point?
They've already threatened to terminate my account, but at this point I'm willing to accept that since I can no longer publish my works.

If there's anything else you'd like to know, please feel free to ask.

I forgot to mention something.
One of the apps that had been rejected immediately was merged with an app that had already been approved in the past, even though it was a bit of a stretch, but I wanted to see what would happen.

So I submitted an update to the app that had already been approved, including the second app that had been rejected for spam.

It was approved almost instantly, in what appeared to be an automatic process.

So, the same app, if submitted on its own, is rejected immediately. If, however, it is merged with another approved app, it is automatically approved.

The approved app was intended for dog lovers, whereas the rejected one was intended for cat lovers. Now they have merged into a single app, which is not ideal since the two apps are quite different.

I cannot do the same for my other apps and games unfortunately....

A rejection one second after "In Review", including TestFlight, means no human looked at the build: an automated check matched it. When that happens to every new app on an account that already has apps live, the match is often between your own apps, or the account itself got flagged after earlier similar submissions.

What I'd do:

  • Stop submitting new apps for now. Each instant rejection adds to the signal, and the guideline says repeated low-effort submissions can lead to removal from the program.
  • Compare your new apps with your 6 live ones: shared code base, shared screens (settings, paywall, onboarding), same icon style, same listing format. If they look like siblings, that's likely what's matching.
  • Pick one new app, make its differences obvious, and reply in App Store Connect with concrete facts: what it does, who it's for, and how it differs from your other apps specifically.
  • If it's still auto-rejected, submit an appeal to the App Review Board. That's the route where a person actually reviews it.

Breakdown of what 4.3 compares (binary, metadata, concept): https://launchray.app/rejections/app-store-guideline-4-3-spam/?utm_source=apple_forums
(Disclosure: I build Launchray, a pre-submission checker.)