All 4 of My Original Native Games Rejected Under Guideline 4.3 & 4.2.6 – No Reply to Appeal/Expedite Request

Hello everyone,

After waiting over a week in review, all of my recently submitted apps were rejected under Guideline 4.3 (Spam) and Guideline 4.2.6 (App Generation Services). The rejection messages are generic and do not specify which components, assets, or metadata triggered the flags.

To clarify, these are original native apps built from scratch in Xcode/Swift—not commercialized templates, web wrappers, or third-party app generation builds—and each has distinct mechanics, custom assets, and functionality.

I have already replied in the Resolution Center, submitted an official appeal/support inquiry, and requested an expedited review, but it has been 3 days with no response.

Has anyone experienced false-positive 4.3/4.2.6 flags across multiple distinct apps on the same developer account, or can an Apple representative advise on what specific areas I should audit to get these resolved?

Thank you in advance for your guidance.

When all apps from one account get 4.3 + 4.2.6 at the same time, it's usually not about each game alone: it's about what they share. 4.3(a) also covers your own apps, not only other developers'.

Things I'd audit:

  • What the 4 games have in common: same base project, same menus/settings/onboarding screens, same UI kit, same icon style, same description structure. To an automated check, 4 games on one code base submitted together can look like one app with 4 skins.
  • Leftovers from asset packs or starters: sample sprites, default fonts, demo levels, placeholder text, file names. 4.2.6 is triggered by things that look like a commercialized template, even if you only used a template for one part.
  • Metadata: if the 4 listings share the same screenshot layout and description pattern, that adds to the match.

What usually works better than appealing all 4 at once:

  1. Pick your strongest game and make its differences obvious (first screens, first screenshot, first sentence).
  2. Resubmit only that one, with review notes stating it's built from scratch in Swift, which parts are custom, and that it's not built with any template or generation service.
  3. If it's still rejected and you're sure it's wrong, appeal that one to the App Review Board.
  4. Then submit the others one by one, each clearly different from the others.

Repeated resubmissions of apps flagged as spam can put the account at risk, so it's worth slowing down here.

More detail on 4.3 here: https://launchray.app/rejections/app-store-guideline-4-3-spam/?utm_source=apple_forums
(Disclosure: I build Launchray, which checks apps against these rules.)