Trials entering billing retry instead of converting

We have a monthly subscription and an annual subscription with a 3-day free trial.

The monthly converts fine. On the annual, trials tend to enter billing retry rather than convert — users don't cancel, the charge just fails.

We've audited our implementation and found nothing on our side that participates in the renewal charge.

What can a developer actually do about this? Does trial length, price point, or using a paid introductory offer instead of a free trial make a difference?

Please file a feedback assistant with the transaction ID which are entering into billing retry. We can investigate on our side if there is anything unusual.

How to File Feedback assistant ticket?
https://feedbackassistant.apple.com/

  • Login with your developer account,
  • Choose "iOS & iPadOS”
  • Choose AppStore
  • “Incorrect & Unexpected behavior"
  • Input the issue description and title.
  • Upload attachments
  • Click “Submit”
  • Copy the Ticket ID “FBxxxxxxx” and let us know.