Hello Apple engineers,
I’m trying to determine whether what I’m seeing is expected behavior or a software issue with the new M5 Pro platform.
System
- MacBook Pro (M5 Pro)
- Latest macOS Beta
- External 5K 165Hz monitor connected via DisplayPort
- Refresh rate correctly detected as 165Hz
What I observe
The display itself is clearly running at 165Hz.
For example:
- Mouse cursor movement is extremely smooth.
- Dragging the desktop by holding an empty area is also perfectly smooth.
However:
- Moving application windows feels much closer to 60Hz.
- Scrolling in Safari, Chrome and other applications also appears to run at a much lower frame rate than the display refresh rate.
- Mission Control animations sometimes show similar micro-stutters.
This makes the cursor and desktop movement noticeably smoother than normal window animations.
⸻
Troubleshooting already performed
- Different DisplayPort cables
- Different timing configurations
- Different resolutions / HiDPI modes
- DSC enabled and disabled
- Refresh rate confirmed at 165Hz
- Same behavior across multiple applications
The issue appears unrelated to the monitor itself because the cursor is clearly rendered at the full refresh rate.
⸻
Additional observation
Interestingly, I previously used another external 4K 144Hz HDR monitor and did not notice this behavior.
I also found another M5 Pro user reporting nearly the same issue:
- external 165Hz display
- smooth cursor
- window dragging jitter / micro-stuttering
At the same time, I haven’t found similar reports from M4 Pro or the base M5 running the same monitor.
⸻
My question
Could this be related to the new M5 Pro display pipeline (WindowServer, Display Engine, or DCP)?
Is there any known issue regarding high-refresh-rate external displays on the M5 Pro platform?
Or is there additional diagnostic logging (WindowServer, DCP, Metal, etc.) that would help identify whether frames are actually being presented at the display refresh rate?
I’d be happy to provide:
- sysdiagnose
- WindowServer logs
- Screen recordings
- Display timing information
- IORegistry dumps
if they would be helpful.
Thank you!
Thanks for filing FB23616959, and for listing the cables, timings, resolutions, and DSC settings you've already ruled out. The report is open and under investigation.
Please continue to test your software in release and pre-release versions of system software made available to you through your developer.apple.com account. When you do, add details about that into your bug report to keep it up to date. Please see developer.apple.com/download.
When you update the report, include a sysdiagnose captured while the stutter is happening. The Profiles and Logs page has instructions for capturing one in macOS. I can't tell from here what's causing the stutter, and I don't know of a documented setting that logs WindowServer frame presentation rates.
The WindowServer crash you describe is an assertion in CA::WindowServer::AppleDisplay::max_src_rect_width_by_pipes(). Please file it as a separate bug report, because the crash and the stutter are separate work items. Attach the crash logs and a sysdiagnose, and post the FB number here.
If you're seeing similar stutter on a high-refresh-rate external display, please file your own report using Feedback Assistant. Include the Mac model, the display model, how it's connected, the refresh rate, and a sysdiagnose captured while the stutter is happening. Then post your FB number here.